In a contemporary review of the album,
Robert Christgau wrote that Kiss "write tough, catchy songs, and if they had a sly,
Jagger-style singer they'd be a menace", but are diminished by appearing as a "caricature" of themselves. Modern reviews are generally positive. Greg Prato of
AllMusic was largely praising of
Rock and Roll Over for the band's "return to the raw hard rock of their first four albums", proclaiming it "one of Kiss' most consistent records". A
Pitchfork reviewer compared the album to
Destroyer, finding it "sonically punchier, if not just a bit lacking in complete vitality". In his ''Collector's Guide to Heavy Metal
, Martin Popoff called Rock and Roll Over
"the most childish Kiss album" and "a disappointment after the amusing ambitions, diversions and excursions of Destroyer''", lamenting the "return to the wee dumb hard rock cartoons of the early albums". In a retrospective review from Beverly Paterson of
Something Else! Said Of Rock And Roll Over: ==Track listing==