Service between Ithaca and South Lansing was operated with streetcars leased from the Ithaca Street Railway. An interchange track with the Lehigh Valley was laid at Remington, near the base of the hill, but the steep grade and limited tractive capacity of the streetcars meant that business was minimal. Service from South Lansing to Auburn was steam-operated. In 1909, a 0.5-mile branch was built by Col. J.V. McIntyre, owner of the
Rogues' Harbor Inn, from his establishment to South Lansing. This was also electrified, and regular service from Ithaca to
Rogues' Harbor Inn was established. Throughout its life, the Short Line (as it was known to residents) faced stiff competition from the Lehigh Valley's Ithaca & Auburn Branch. The two-car maximum up the hill out of Ithaca effectively guaranteed to the LV the freight business of Ithaca, but the Short Line offered four trains a day between Ithaca and Auburn, against two for the Lehigh Valley. However, the Short Line lacked the financial resources of the Lehigh Valley, and struggled in the harsh upstate winters. It went into receivership in 1912 and was reorganized as the
Central New York Southern Railroad in 1914 (organized May 28; property of NYA&L conveyed July 14). At this time the initial grade out of Ithaca was eased somewhat with the construction of an S-shaped approach from Percy Field, replacing the use of the steeper Cayuga Heights loop of the Ithaca Street Railway; this is the abutment over East Shore Drive that is still in place. This gentler grade allowed the use of gas-powered
McKeen cars through to Auburn, so that passengers no longer needed to change from electric to steam in South Lansing. The purchase of two
McKeen cars to speed the Ithaca-Auburn run could not put off insolvency forever. However, because the City of Ithaca refused permission for the McKeen cars to run down Tioga Street, passengers from downtown Ithaca still had to transfer, now at a spur on the east side of Percy Field, just below the Lakeview Cemetery. The Rogues Harbor spur was closed on October 19, 1920, and the last run on the main line was made on October 19, 1923. The railroad was formally abandoned in 1924, and rail was removed in 1925, except for the line from Ithaca to Remington, which was operated by the
Ithaca Traction Corporation to serve a powerhouse until 1931. ==Relics==