Impressed by the success Ricciardi and Beane were having with the low-budget Athletics, the
Toronto Blue Jays, who sought to cut payroll while becoming more competitive after their acquisition by
Canadian media giant
Rogers Communications, sought Ricciardi's services after firing then-general manager
Gord Ash. During his tenure, the Blue Jays never made the playoffs, coming closest in 2006, when they finished second in their division. He signed a five-year contract with Toronto after the 2002 season, which was extended to 2010 after the 2005 season. After arriving in Toronto, one of Ricciardi's first deals was to send hard-throwing reliever
Billy Koch to the Athletics for third baseman
Eric Hinske and pitcher
Justin Miller. Over the next few years, Ricciardi would develop a reputation for coziness with his former team, making deals with Oakland for starting pitcher
Cory Lidle in November
2002 and another starting pitcher,
Ted Lilly, in November
2003. After a surprising 2003 campaign, which saw the emergence of
Roy Halladay and
Vernon Wells, the team suffered its worst season since
1980, in
2004, mainly due to injuries to key players such as Wells and star slugger
Carlos Delgado. Delgado became a free agent in the off-season, and for financial reasons the Blue Jays did not seriously pursue re-signing him; the
Florida Marlins eventually inked him to a contract. During the 2004 season, Ricciardi hired former Shelby teammate
John Gibbons as the Blue Jays' new manager. Gibbons remained as Blue Jays' manager until being fired on June 20, 2008. Ricciardi's arrival in Toronto had been greeted with great optimism and enthusiasm after the team had suffered through several disappointing seasons. The enthusiasm steadily waned, however, as the team repeatedly failed to qualify for the postseason.
2005 Ricciardi was given more freedom to move after Blue Jays owner
Ted Rogers expanded the team's payroll to $210 million over three years prior to the
2005 season. In the
2005 MLB draft, Ricciardi famously drafted
Ricky Romero instead of
Troy Tulowitzki, overruling the recommendations of his scouting staff. While Romero would have modest success, even being named to the
2011 MLB All-Star Game as a Blue Jay before eventually being released by the team, Tulowitzki would have the better career, winning multiple awards with the
Colorado Rockies. Coincidentally, Tulowitzki would join the Blue Jays 10 years later in a trade executed by Riccardi's successor,
Alex Anthopoulos.
2006 After the 2005 season (in which the Blue Jays posted an 80–82 record), Ricciardi began working to improve Toronto's pitching, signing free agent starter
A. J. Burnett and closer
B.J. Ryan. He also secured two big bats in first baseman
Lyle Overbay and slugging third baseman
Troy Glaus via the trade bloc, and signed
Gold Glove-winning catcher
Bengie Molina as well. The additions paid significant dividends for the team in
2006, as the Blue Jays finished second in the tough
American League East with an 87–75 record. It was the first time Toronto had finished above third in the division since winning the
1993 World Series.
2007 Seeking to upgrade the everyday lineup as well, Ricciardi signed a two-year contract with experienced slugger and designated hitter
Frank Thomas. However, due to his slow start in 2008, in which he batted just .167 with three home runs in his first 60 at-bats, Thomas was released in April of that year. Ricciardi also signed veteran shortstop
Royce Clayton as a "stopgap" measure to shore up the middle infield for the
2007 season. During spring training of 2007,
B.J. Ryan was suffering from an injury that Ricciardi initially reported to be a result of a bad back. It was later revealed that it was not a back injury that he was suffering from at all, but rather a more severe elbow injury which subsequently required season ending
Tommy John surgery. When asked why he was not more upfront about Ryan's injury situation, Ricciardi responded by saying, "They're not lies if we know the truth."
2008 Despite the lack of hitting on his 2008 ball club, Ricciardi had assembled one of the more effective pitching staffs in Major League Baseball, bolstered by bullpen pick-ups such as
Scott Downs,
Brian Tallet,
Jesse Carlson, and
Shawn Camp. Over the season, the team had the best ERA in baseball at 3.49 and the bullpen ERA of 2.94. Early in the season, the Jays struggled, and the team fired manager John Gibbons, replacing him with former manager
Cito Gaston. Toronto ended the season on a high note, finishing with a final record of 86 wins and 76 losses, the organization's third-best showing since the 1993 season. In the middle of June 2008, with the Jays in last place in the American League East, Ricciardi appeared on local Toronto sports radio station
The FAN 590, in which he fielded questions from fans. One fan insisted that the Jays should actively seek to acquire
Cincinnati Reds outfielder
Adam Dunn, to which Ricciardi responded with very negative personal comments about Dunn's passion for the game of baseball: On June 24, 2008, Ricciardi told Toronto media that he received a personal phone call from Dunn and personally apologized for the ad-lib comments, a conversation Dunn vehemently refuted in an interview with MLB.com. Some again questioned Ricciardi's trustworthiness, but Ricciardi said, "All I know is the person I talked to said it was Adam Dunn. That's quite a prank to pull."
2009 During Roy Halladay's last home start of the
2009 season on September 25, a sign in the 500 level stating "Fire JP!" was hung over the railing. The sign was taken away by security at the bottom of the 2nd inning. With two games remaining in what was a disappointing 2009 season, Ricciardi was fired on October 3, 2009. The day before Blue Jays players had gone public with criticism over Gaston's managing style, and had asked for a meeting with team president
Paul Beeston. His firing was widely expected. Anthopoulos was eventually made the permanent general manager for the Jays. ==New York Mets==