Reedman began to make his mark as an
Australian rules footballer in 1884, whilst playing parklands football for Medindie. He went on to join Hotham who were in the Adelaide Suburban Association (ASA) competition, and was a key member of the club's 1885 premiership side. He captained Hotham when they again won the ASA premiership in 1886.
Hotham joined the
South Australian Football Association (SAFA) in 1887, with Reedman as captain. Just prior to the 1888 football season, Hotham changed their name to North Adelaide (no connection to the
current club) and again Reedman was captain. When Hotham/North Adelaide amalgamated with the
Adelaide club in 1889, Reedman moved to
South Adelaide, where he was appointed captain, a position he held until 1898, playing 172 consecutive matches (bringing his total to 200) and leading South to five premierships in seven years before the introduction of electorate football (whereby footballers had to play for their local team) forced his move to North Adelaide in 1899. Reedman led
North Adelaide from 1901 to 1905, and in that time the club won premierships in 1902 and 1905, with Reedman also being part of the 1900 premiership team. He also captained
South Australia in 1903, and in 1907 played both his 300th game - only the second ever player in elite Australian rules football to do so - as well as his 306th game to break the elite Australian rules football games record held by Victorian
Peter Burns. Following his retirement from playing, Reedman was appointed coach of the lowly
West Adelaide Football Club in 1908. To the end of 1907, West Adelaide had won only 23 and drawn 1 of the 145 SAFA matches they had played, and had been perennially close to or on the bottom of the ladder. Reedman coached West Adelaide to its first ever premiership in 1908, and then defeated
Victorian Football League (VFL) premiers
Carlton Football Club to become
Champions of Australia. Reedman promptly left West Adelaide to return to North Adelaide for one last season as a player at the age of 43, but it was an inauspicious finale, as the red and whites finished second last. Reedman played 115 matches for North Adelaide, bringing his career total to 319 matches, which remained a record in South Australian elite football until it was broken by
Lindsay Head in 1970, while his 200 consecutive matches was a record in elite football until it was broken by
Jack Titus in 1943. His brother
Sid also captained South Adelaide. ==Cricket career==