.|alt=Gargan Hall inside Bapst Library On July 1, 1937, McGarry was appointed to succeed Louis J. Gallagher as the
president of Boston College. While he initially attempting to maintain a full undergraduate and graduate teaching load in addition to his presidency, this proved untenable after one semester, as his health began to deteriorate. He also reorganized the administration of the college's Intown Division, which was a two-year, accelerated, pre-law program for preparation to enroll in the
Law School. In 1938, Boston College changed its admission requirements, allowing students to substitute an approved secondary school certification for the college's entrance examination. In February 1938, For this, McGarry is considered the business school's founder. In 1937,
Francis X. Talbot, the president of
America Press informed McGarry of his desire to establish a Jesuit theology journal in the United States, and that he wanted McGarry to be its first editor-in-chief. In July 1938, McGarry presided over a conference held at
Inisfada, The conference unanimously decided to select McGarry to become the editor-in-chief of the new publication,
Theological Studies. The provincial superior, James H. Dolan, permitted McGarry's appointment even though he had been president of Boston College for only two years, an unusual occurrence. He was also succeeded by Murphy as pastor of St. Ignatius Loyola Church. == Editor of
Theological Studies ==