McCracken was playing his football in Port Macquarie when he was spotted by
Canterbury-Bankstown Bulldogs Chief Executive
Peter Moore who persuaded the young Centre to join The Bulldogs in
1991, and he ended up staying with the club until 1995, although he also spent the 1992/93 English season with
St. Helens. During the
Super League war he joined the
Parramatta Eels being appointed co-captain, before moving to the
Wests Tigers in 2000 where he became the franchise's first captain. Jarrod McCracken played at in
St. Helens' 4–5 defeat by
Wigan in the
1992 Lancashire Cup Final during the
1992–93 season at
Knowsley Road,
St. Helens, on Sunday 18 October 1992. McCracken played in Canterbury's
1994 Grand Final loss to the
Canberra Raiders. McCracken's luck with Grand Finals was against him again in
1995. As a result of the
Super League war and his mid-season announcement that he would be leaving the Bulldogs at the end of the year to join the
ARL loyal club Parramatta, McCracken missed out on the Dogs historic
1995 Grand Final win over
Manly-Warringah when they became the first team to win the premiership from outside the top four (they finished the regular season in 6th with a 14–8 record compared to Manly finishing 1st with a 20–2 record which included a 26–0 mauling of the renamed Sydney Bulldogs in Round 9 at
Parramatta Stadium). As a result of his impending departure from the club, Bulldogs coach
Chris Anderson dropped McCracken to
reserve grade despite him playing in the top grade for the first 19 games of the season and having represented New Zealand in tests against both France and
Australia. Because of this, McCracken preferred to sit out the Bulldogs finals campaign rather than try to fight his way back into the team, unlike his team mates
Dean Pay,
Jim Dymock and
Jason Smith who were also dropped by Anderson for the same reason. McCracken made his debut for Parramatta in 1996 against South Queensland scoring a try in a 24–20 loss. In 1997, McCracken played 21 games as Parramatta finished 3rd and qualified for the finals for the first time since 1986. Parramatta then went on to lose both finals matches against Newcastle and North Sydney in which they led both games at half time before capitulating in the second half. In 1998, McCracken co-captained Parramatta and change positions moving into the forwards. Parramatta finished 4th at the end of the season and qualified for the finals. McCracken played in all 3 finals games for the club including the preliminary final loss to his former team Canterbury. With Parramatta leading 18–2 with less than 10 minutes to play, Canterbury staged a comeback scoring 3 tries in 8 minutes with Canterbury player
Daryl Halligan kicking 2 goals from the sideline to tie the game at 18–18. Parramatta player
Paul Carige then made a series of personal errors which cost Parramatta dearly in extra time with Canterbury going on to win 32–20. The game is often referred to as one of the biggest preliminary final chokes of all time. In 1999, McCracken played nearly every game for Parramatta as they finished 2nd on the table at the end of the regular season. Parramatta reached the preliminary final against Melbourne where they led 16–0 at half time before a second half capitulation ended with the club losing 18–16. The match was also McCracken's last for Parramatta. ==Representative career==