Both the PC and Xbox versions of the game were well received. The PC version holds an aggregate score of 81 out of 100 on
Metacritic based on 34 reviews, Critics lauded the lightsaber interface and player customization options. Ernie Halal of Gaming Age gave the game an A−, writing, "You choose not only the gender and race of your character, but also which powers and fighting styles to develop [...] Third person adventure games rarely offer that much customization." Critics noted that, despite its age, the
Quake III engine was used well. Some critics did, however, note that the engine was starting to look dated. and as "strong" by Gaming Age. Game Over Online was critical of the mission structure, writing "This kind of free-form mission assignment [...] only serves to weaken the plotline. It also leads to a disjointedness to the missions [...] it seems more like roaming than any actual story advancement."
GameSpots Craig Beers, however, praised the mission structure; "
Jedi Academy does an excellent job of balancing its missions."
IGN also defended the system; "It's nice that the game offers a series of fairly short, relatively unconnected missions at the start. It's a great way to get your feet wet and ease you in to the environments and the saber fighting before the challenge level ramps up." The
AI was criticized by
PC Gamer UK as "laughable"; "Every encounter you have is filled with people too stupid to realise that running away or taking some sort of cover would be the best option. [
Jedi Academy] requires little to no skill to play through." This opinion was echoed by
GameSpot: "Stormtroopers usually just stand there shooting away at you [...] Dark Jedi rush at you, even after watching four of their brethren plummet to a horrible death. Occasionally, you'll see an enemy accidentally commit suicide by falling off a cliff or falling into lava, enemies will not even dive for cover or try and throw it back if you throw an uncooked thermal detonator at them." Despite his criticism of the AI,
GameSpots Craig Beers scored the game 8.4 out of 10, writing "It manages to take all the fun parts from its predecessor and greatly expands them to create an engaging, new action game in its own right."
IGNs Steve Butts scored the game 8.8 out of 10, giving it an "Editor's Choice Award" and writing "If you like
Star Wars and think flipping around chopping up Stormtroopers and flinging Dark Jedi off of conveniently placed precipices is fun, then this game is definitely for you."
Eurogamers Kristan Reed was less impressed, scoring the game 7 out of 10, writing "The harsh reality is, for all the plentiful additions, there's much work to be done before LucasArts can boast it has created the ultimate
Star Wars FPS. Sure, it's the best one yet, but with some often laughable AI and creaking tech underpinning it, the flaws are there for all to see."
Xbox Kevin Gifford of
1Up.com scored the Xbox version a B−. He lauded the addition of
Xbox Live support and the ability to use a lightsaber from the opening, two of biggest criticisms of
Jedi Outcast. However, he called the graphics "worryingly out of date by current Xbox standards", saying that when playing in first-person mode "the game looks more like a two-year-old PC shooter than a modern
Star Wars game." He concluded that "The Xbox Live games make
Jedi Academy worth at least a rental to online players, but otherwise, this game's worth it to
Star Wars fans only."
Eurogamers Kristan Reed was also somewhat unimpressed, scoring the game 6 out of 10 and criticizing the controls; "In common with the PC version, you still find yourself going into battle and fumbling furiously through cyclical menus while numerous baddies are busy blasting seven shades out of you." She was also critical of the
AI and the graphics, concluding that "It's good to see Live make the package this time around, but we're disappointed that after all these years LucasArts is still scratching around abusing the
Star Wars brand in this way. There are some good ideas here that haven't been realised, and we're once again left waiting for the definitive
Star Wars FPS to appear."
IGN were more impressed, scoring the game 8 out of 10. Although they were critical of the graphics and
frame rate and found the game to be inferior to
Jedi Outcast, reviewer Steve Butts concluded, "For the 15 or so hours that it lasted, I enjoyed
Jedi Academy."
GameSpots Craig Beers scored the game 8.1 out of 10. He praised the mapping of the PC version's controls to the
Xbox Controller and the implementation of Xbox Live, but like
IGN, he was critical of the frame rates. He concluded that "The game may not look great, but it translates well to the Xbox--for those who would prefer to play it on a console. It even caters to those who aren't familiar with the
Star Wars universe and just want pure action. In general,
Jedi Knight: Jedi Academy is highly recommendable."
GameZones Nick Valentino scored the game 8.2 out of 10 and was especially impressed with the use of Xbox live; "the biggest draw--and the one that has me playing this one very often--is the fact that the multiplayer modes can also be played online using the Xbox Live service. That's right, you read it correctly. You can duel against other Xbox gamers out there using any of the seven multiplayer modes and even talk trash using your Xbox Communicator. Here's your chance to see if you're truly good with the lightsaber." ==See also==