Between 1924 and 1933, Fauset published four novels:
There is Confusion (1924),
Plum Bun (1928),
The Chinaberry Tree (1931), and
Comedy, American Style (1933). She believed that
T. S. Stribling's novel
Birthright, written by a white man about black life, could not fully portray her people. Fauset thought there was a dearth of positive depictions of African-American lives in contemporary literature. She was inspired to portray African-American life both as realistically, and as positively, as possible, and wrote about the middle-class life she knew of as an educated person. At the same time, she worked to explore contemporary issues of identity among African Americans, including issues related to the community's assessment of skin color. Many were of
mixed race with some European ancestry. The Great Migration resulted in many African Americans moving to industrial cities; in some cases, individuals used this change as freedom to try on new identities. Some used partial European ancestry and appearance to
pass as white, for temporary convenience or advantage: for instance, to get better service in a store or restaurant, or to gain a job. Others entered white society nearly permanently to take advantage of economic and social opportunities, sometimes leaving darker-skinned relatives behind. This issue was explored by other writers of the Harlem Renaissance in addition to Fauset, who was herself light-skinned and visibly of mixed race. Vashti Crutcher Lewis, in an essay entitled "Mulatto Hegemony in the Novels of Jessie Redmon Fauset", suggests that Fauset's novels illustrate the evidence of a color hierarchy with lighter-skinned blacks enjoying more privilege." •
There is Confusion was widely praised upon release. In the
New York Times,
Ernest Boyd wrote: "Compared with the ordinary story of negro life Jessie Redmon Fauset's
There is Confusion assumes the proportions of an important book; it is well executed, so well, in fact, that no Ku Kluxer could stand it."
Alain Locke wrote in
The Crisis: "[H]ere in refreshing contrast with the bulk of fiction about the Negro, we have a novel of the educated and aspiring classes." This novel traces the family histories of Joanna Mitchell and Peter Bye, who must each come to terms with their complex racial histories. •
Plum Bun has warranted the most critical attention. It explores the theme of "
passing". The
mixed-race protagonist, Angela Murray, who has partial European ancestry, passes for white in order to gain some advantages. In the course of the novel, she eventually reclaims her African-American identity. •
The Chinaberry Tree has not received much critical attention. Set in New Jersey, this novel explores the longing for "respectability" among the contemporary African-American middle class. The protagonist Laurentine seeks to overcome her "bad blood" through marriage to a "decent" man. Ultimately, Laurentine must redefine "respectable" as she finds her own sense of identity. •
Comedy, American Style, Fauset's last novel, explores the destructive power of "color mania" among African Americans, some of whom discriminated within the black community on the basis of skin color. The protagonist's mother Olivia brings about the downfall of the other characters due to her own such internalized racism. == Contemporary reviews ==