In the mid-1950s, Johnston moved to New York City to study dance under
Jose Limón, but turned to writing after she broke her foot. Beginning in 1959, Johnston served as the dance critic for
The Village Voice, the weekly downtown newspaper for New York City. She was friendly with many performers, performance artists, composers, poets and artists associated with the
Judson Dance Theater, and championed
postmodern movements like
Fluxus and artists like
Yvonne Rainier,
Robert Morris,
Merce Cunningham, and
Lucinda Childs. During the late 1960s,
Deborah Jowitt joined the paper and wrote a regular dance column for
the Voice, while Johnston's dance column became a kind of weekly diary, chronicling her adventures in the New York art world. Johnston was a member of a 1971 New York City panel produced by Shirley Broughton as part of the "Theater for Ideas" series. The event was a vigorous debate on feminism with
Norman Mailer, author;
Germaine Greer, author;
Diana Trilling, literary critic;
Jacqueline Ceballos,
National Organization for Women president, and Johnston herself. The event was also billed as an intellectual "Battle of the Sexes" – effectively promoting Mailer's then-just-published, feminism-critical book
The Prisoner of Sex (1971). When the time came for her to make her introductory remarks, Johnston read a poem, after which two feminist friends came onstage and the three simulated (fully dressed) three-way lesbian sex) and quickly exited. Despite this colorful interruption, Greer and Mailer continued to exchange verbal blows with each other (and the audience) for the remainder of the 3½ hour event. This event was widely written about (since so many writers were in attendance, including
Susan Sontag and
Cynthia Ozick) and filmed by the now-legendary documentary filmmaker
D. A. Pennebaker, eventually becoming the cult-documentary titled
Town Bloody Hall. As this incident illustrates, Johnston's self-described "east west flower child beat hip
psychedelic paradise now love peace do your own thing approach to the revolution" (as she called it in
Lesbian Nation) often confounded her feminist allies as much as it did the conservative foes of gay and lesbian liberation. As recorded in
Lesbian Nation, Johnston often was at the center of controversies within the feminist movement of the 1960s and 1970s. She famously went on record stating that "all women are lesbians except those that don't know it yet." In her work
Films Out of Focus, specifically in the 1972 edition, Johnston presents enigmatic phrases that captivate the reader's attention, encouraging introspection. Her writing includes discussions about feminism, particularly the assertion that lesbians are feminists, not solely defined by their sexuality. In 1973, she predicted
"an end to the catastrophic brotherhood and a return to the former glory and wise equanimity of the matriarchies." Johnston was also one of the first countercultural and lesbian writers at
Ms. magazine, eventually coming to the conclusion that the magazine was too mainstream, ultimately presenting feminism as palatable, family-friendly and safe. According to author
Vivian Gornick: For radical feminists like me,
Ellen Willis, and Jill Johnston, we had a different kind of magazine in mind. We came out against marriage and motherhood.
Gloria Steinem was uptown; we were downtown. She hung out with
Establishment figures; we had only ourselves. It very quickly became obvious at that first meeting that they wanted a glossy that would appeal to the women who read the ''
Ladies' Home Journal''. We didn't want that, so they walked away with it. On another occasion, Johnston grew bored at a poolside press conference given by feminist
Betty Friedan, and so decided to strip off her top and take a swim. In 1977, Johnson became an associate of the
Women's Institute for Freedom of the Press (WIFP). WIFP is an American nonprofit publishing organization. The organization works to increase communication between women and connect the public with forms of women-based media. Johnston's career as a dance critic was hampered by the controversy that attended the publication of
Lesbian Nation and the publicity engendered by her dramatic style of lesbian feminist activism. as well as the autobiographies
Mother Bound and
Paper Daughter. Described by one critic as "part
Gertrude Stein, part
E. E. Cummings, with a dash of
Jack Kerouac thrown for good measure," Johnston's freeform, fluid writing style of the 1970s matched the colorful nature of the tales recounted in her books
Lesbian Nation and
Gullibles Travels. Her later work as a literary and
art critic for
Art in America and the
New York Times Review of Books is more standard in tone and content. Early writing not collected in other volumes can be found in
Admission Accomplished while the critical biography
Jasper Johns represents an example of her later style. She also performed in
John Cage's
Music Walk in 1962, and
Karlheinz Stockhausen's
Jill Johnston Dancing. ==Personal life==