Jesse played the
mandolin with a unique, self-invented "
crosspicking" and "split-string" playing method, and Jim sang as a
high tenor and played
guitar. They played with their backing band, The Virginia Boys, consisting of a five-string
banjo,
fiddle, and
bass player. The Virginia Boys have included musicians such as fiddler
Vassar Clements, banjo player
Allen Shelton, Mike Scott, Vic Jordan, Bobby Thompson,
Carl Jackson, fiddler Jimmy Buchanan, Glen Duncan, Jesse's oldest son, the late Keith McReynolds,
Randall Franks, and many more. After the death of his brother Jim, Jesse continued to perform with their Virginia Boys band. He still performed in the bluegrass music tradition, but added other genres of music to his repertoire, including
Chuck Berry and
Grateful Dead songs. Jesse participated in a 2010 tribute to
Jerry Garcia and
Robert Hunter titled
Jesse McReynolds & Friends Tribute to Jerry Garcia and Robert Hunter: Songs of the Grateful Dead, released on Woodstock Records. It features Garcia's friends
David Nelson and
Sandy Rothman, along with Stu Allen, of the present
Jerry Garcia Acoustic Band. Jesse's band line-up included Keith's son, Garrett McReynolds, as tenor singer/rhythm guitarist. On special occasions, Jesse took out the historic fiddle his grandfather played on the Bristol Sessions, and let his grandson Luke McKnight do the cross-picking that Jesse created. Rounding out the group was Travis Wetzel on fiddle, Gary Reece on banjo, and Larry Carney on guitar. ==Recordings==