There is a general consensus that
The Onion made an impact on Biden's public image. In 2014, Jonathan Bernstein at
Bloomberg Opinion attributed Biden's image to a combination of
The Onions character and the vice president's own actions and personality. "All veeps become ridiculous; the only question is how", Bernstein wrote, and "once the
Onion came up with the image, it seemed to fit really well." Scholar Byron C. Wallace suggested
The Onions patently absurd, often risqué characterization of Biden would be easily recognized as implausible by most readers and that, as such, their articles about Biden were presumptively less likely to be mistaken for real news than other, subtler satirical content. On the other hand, the heightened contrast between the fiction and the real person has prompted concern that readers' impression of
The Onions Biden could supplant their impression of the real Biden.
The Onion editor Tracy remarked in 2012: "My sense is that we've done so much on him that our vision for our version of Joe Biden has, in some way, seeped into the nation's consciousness [and] people think our character of Joe Biden is somehow him." In a profile of Biden for
The New Republic, George Blaustein asked: Nevertheless, it remains difficult to quantify
The Onions impact on Biden's image, and so the precise extent of the newspaper's influence is unclear. Jeremy Gordon at
The Outline doubted the extent of
The Onions effect on Biden's popularity, noting that the website's audience had decreased in the preceding years and that its audience skewed younger and more liberal than Biden's base of predominantly older, moderate Democrats. Conversely, historian Christine Wenc has argued that
The Onion's dominance in its home state of Wisconsin helped Biden to win it as the third-closest state of the
2020 United States presidential election.
In Internet culture The Onions Biden became a popular
meme and influenced perceptions of Biden in
Internet culture, particularly during the Obama administration. Seth Millstein at the women's magazine
Bustle ranked
The Onion character as the 13th best Biden meme (out of 15) and said it had "played an enormous role in shaping the public's perception of Biden." Regarding Biden's chances of appealing to
Millennial voters in the 2020 Democratic presidential primaries,
Peter Hamby at
Vanity Fair wrote that Biden may be "old, but thanks to the
Onion and his Uncle Joe persona, he's already optimized for meme culture." In addition to becoming a meme in its own right,
The Onions Biden influenced other memes and online discourse about Biden, which frequently imagined him as a roguish goof paired with Obama as the more serious "
straight man". A viral tweet from Twitter user @blippoblappo played off this dynamic: Brian Feldman at
New York magazine wrote that "Biden-joke pedants might point out that the butt-rock-loving Biden of the
Onion would probably not be a Wu-Tang Clan fan," but @blippoblappo's tweet "nevertheless carries with it the same myth-making potency: an image that it feels more true than the actual truth."
In the Congressional Record The character entered the
Congressional Record on at least two occasions. During the
presidential transition of Donald Trump,
Mitch McConnell referenced the character in a December 2016 speech to the Senate floor delivered in tribute to Biden. McConnell said, "When
The Onion ran a mock photo of him washing a Trans Am in the White House driveway shirtless, America embraced it. And so did he." In June 2019, while giving testimony to the
House Intelligence Committee on the topic of "
deepfake" imagery, former FBI agent
Clint Watts discussed
The Onions manipulated photo of Biden washing a car shirtless. Some members of Congress later pointed to the
Onion image as an example of potential problems with
moderating deepfake imagery—namely, the difficulty of trying to distinguish between
satire and
fake news.
Criticism from former Onion editor (
pictured in 2010) expressed regret over the paper's approach to Biden.
Joe Garden—a former
Onion writer and editor who left in 2012 after 19 years—publicly criticized the newspaper's portrayal of Biden in May 2019. After he tweeted some of his recent thoughts about the character,
Vice published a full op-ed by Garden titled "Area Man Regrets Helping Turn Joe Biden into a Meme". In the
Vice piece, Garden wrote that he still believed the Biden pieces were funny in their light-hearted way. However, he had also come to believe they had failed as satire because of viciously skewering a public figure who deserved scrutiny, we let him off easy". In hindsight, he said, Biden's vocal approval of the character should have been a
red flag indicating that their satire was ineffective. He compared their work to Trump's appearance as the host of
Saturday Night Live in 2015 and
Jimmy Fallon's interview with Trump on
The Tonight Show in 2016, both of which had been criticized as overly conciliatory treatments that downplayed what he felt were
inflammatory and racist aspects of Trump's messaging. Garden concluded: Garden's op-ed was discussed in
The Washington Post and
The New York Times. ==Retirement of the character (2019–present)==