Heraud was identified as a leading figure in the "Syncretics", a proto-aesthetic group mocked in
Punch and prominent around 1840. After a few years the excitement around their eclectic approach subsided. A biographer of
Ralph Waldo Emerson, who initially took a great interest, has called Heraud in particular a "general failure".
The group Other Syncretics were
Francis Foster Barham,
Richard Henry Horne, and
John Westland Marston. It grew out of an earlier group round
James Pierrepont Greaves, the "Aesthetic Society" or "Aesthetic Institution", based in Burton Street on the north side of
Bloomsbury, with a core of Greaves and a few neighbours. Heraud and Barham took over the
Monthly Magazine, and it functioned as the organ of the group in the period 1839 to 1841.
Camilla Toulmin gained the impression in 1841, visiting Horne, that there was a group of younger and ambitious men in the Syncretics, besides the better-known names. For example, the Syncretics took up the
Festus of
Philip James Bailey.
Transatlantic ties The group also found kinship with, and encouragement from, the New England
transcendentalists. He also sent books to Greaves and Heraud; Greaves sent back books including Heraud's
Lecture on Poetic Genius. Approval of the
Monthly Magazine was strong from Alcott,
Convers Francis and
George Ripley. Heraud published one piece from New England in 1839, an oration by Robert Bartlett. It proved a false start, though. Later in the year the transcendentalists founded their own periodical,
The Dial, along the same lines. Writing in
The Dial in 1842, Emerson in his article
English Reformers praised Heraud as an interpreter of
Jakob Boehme and
Emanuel Swedenborg; and referenced his papers
Foreign Aids to Self Intelligence, which had been announced as a three-volume work. Heraud took Emerson to be a disciple of Carlyle, and was contradicted in
The Present. A few years later he was explaining that Swedenborg was to be taken only as an example and inspiration, since the transcendentalist approach was at odds with an established church. It was through the pages of the
Monthly Magazine that two notable Swedenborgians,
James John Garth Wilkinson and
Henry James Sr., came to know each other. Carlyle in fact disapproved of the group around Heraud and Alcott House, Greaves's project. These included
John Goodwyn Barmby,
Newton Crosland, Horne,
Henry Mansel, and
James Elishama Smith. A circumstantial account,
"Damned" Tragedies, was given in the July 1842 ''Fraser's Magazine''. Bernard's talk was light-hearted chat about actors, but Heraud and
Frederick Guest Tomlins addressed more serious aspects and limitations of current British theatre, before the weekly series outstayed its welcome at the Gallery. The Syncretics, who included also
George Stephens, became active in agitation to have unperformed drama staged. The context was the restriction in London to three theatres with patents, and an absence of new
verse drama productions. Not short of ambition, the Dramatic Committee of the Association, through Heraud, pressed for a reformed and poetic theatre, an actors' joint stock company, and the performance of new work, as well as drama schools to elevate taste. A failed demonstration,
Martinuzzi of 1841, written by Stephens, led to Heraud in particular being lampooned in
Punch, by
William Makepeace Thackeray. The existing theatrical monopoly was, however, abolished by the
Theatres Act 1843. Heraud himself wrote dramas and persisted. The tragedy of
Videna, based on
Geoffrey of Monmouth, was acted at the Marylebone Theatre in 1854, with
James William Wallack; and
Wife or No Wife and a version of
Ernest Legouvé's
Medea were staged later. == Heraud as poet ==