Kissell was selected by the
National Football League's
Los Angeles Rams in the 12th round of the
1947 draft, but instead joined the
Buffalo Bills of the rival
All-America Football Conference (AAFC) in 1948. Buffalo finished the regular season 7–7 in a tie with the
Baltimore Colts for first place in the AAFC East. After beating the Colts in a playoff, the Bills lost the AAFC championship game to the
Cleveland Browns. Kissell was named an
All-Pro defensive tackle by the
International News Service after the season. The AAFC disbanded at the end of 1949 because of financial struggles stemming from poor attendance and competition over player salaries, and three of its teams – the Browns, Colts and
San Francisco 49ers – were absorbed by the NFL. In 1950, players from the AAFC's defunct teams – including the Bills – went into a
dispersal draft. Kissell, however, was sold along with
halfback Rex Bumgardner and
guard (American football) Abe Gibron to the Browns in a deal that gave Bills owner
James Breuil a 25% share in the team. In the Browns, Kissell joined a team that had won all of the AAFC's four championships behind an offense that featured
quarterback Otto Graham,
fullback Marion Motley and
ends
Mac Speedie and
Dante Lavelli. Yet while the Browns had been the league's best team, many sportswriters and owners doubted that the team would continue its string of success in the NFL starting in 1950. Cleveland began the season by beating the previous year's NFL champion
Philadelphia Eagles and went on to win the
NFL championship over the
Los Angeles Rams. Kissell finished his education at Boston College in 1950, graduating with a bachelor's degree in education and government. Sportswriters named Kissell a second-team
All-Pro after the season. The Browns again contended for the NFL championship in 1952 but lost to the
Detroit Lions. After that season, Kissell decided to jump to the
Canadian Football League, signing with the
Ottawa Rough Riders for $9,500 a year plus bonuses – $2,000 more than he was making with the Browns. He joined numerous other NFL players, including teammate Mac Speedie, in a player exodus to the CFL, which was trying to build its talent pool by offering better salaries to American players. The move, however, prompted a drawn-out legal case between the Browns and the Rough Riders in the Canadian courts at the beginning of the 1953 season. The Browns and Rough Riders settled their differences the following April, agreeing to send Kissell back to Cleveland. Bob Jauron, a coach from Nashua, had been hired to lead the team, which played in the
Ontario Rugby Football Union. ==Later life and death==