Gerrard returned to active political life in 1998, as leader of the
Manitoba Liberal Party. After winning only three seats in the
1995 provincial election and losing its official status in the legislature (which it had enjoyed since
1988), the provincial Liberal Party had nearly disintegrated in 1997 under the leadership of
Ginny Hasselfield. She resigned in February 1998, and Gerrard declared his candidacy to succeed her. Supported by former leader
Sharon Carstairs, he defeated the only other candidate, former
Sagkeeng First Nation chief
Jerry Fontaine.
Elections 1999 Gerrard set modest goals for his party in the
1999 provincial election, saying that the Liberals could win between ten and fifteen seats to hold the balance of power in a
minority government. He focused his attention on health care, and pledged that he would serve as his own
Minister of Health if elected as
Premier. He also promised to appoint a health
ombudsman, commit $25 million toward repairing provincial infrastructure, provide $20 million for post-secondary education, end provincial clawbacks of federal tax credits for welfare recipients, and create a new Ministry of Digital Economy and the Information Highway. The Liberal Party was unable to run a full electoral slate, fielding candidates in only 50 of 57 divisions. Gerrard tried to deflect criticism by joking that he would "put his 50 Liberal candidates up against 57 Tory and NDP candidates any day", but the failure to run a full slate unquestionably damaged his party's prospects. On election day, Gerrard personally defeated incumbent Progressive Conservative
cabinet minister Mike Radcliffe in the upscale
Winnipeg division of
River Heights, which Carstairs had previously represented, but the Liberals won no other seats. The party's popular vote fell from 23% to 13%, as many former Liberal voters shifted to the victorious New Democratic Party under
Gary Doer. Gerrard was the only Liberal member of the Manitoba legislature between 1999 and 2003. He was not personally blamed for the party's loss, and was reaffirmed as party leader in 2000.
2003 Popular support for the Liberal Party increased after the 1999 election, reaching 24% in July 2001 and remaining in the low twenties throughout 2002 and 2003. The party entered the 2003 election in a much improved position from four years earlier: their divisions were largely resolved and their financial situation more secure, and they were able to field a candidate in every division. Gerrard promised tax cuts for Manitobans under thirty and the elimination of the province's payroll tax, and committed to a "health-care guarantee" wherein the government would fund out-of-province health care if services could not be provided within Manitoba. He also promised to create an organization that would integrate health services from different fields, and to establish community health centres for seniors. Liberal support declined in the final stage of the campaign, and the party ultimately polled a slightly lower percentage of votes relative to its 1999 result. Gerrard was nevertheless returned without difficulty in River Heights, and former
Member of the Legislative Assembly (MLA)
Kevin Lamoureux gave the party a second seat by retaking his old division of
Inkster.
2007 The Liberal Party's
2007 campaign was centred around five issues: health care waiting lists, threatened emergency room closures in Winnipeg, university funding, urban sprawl, and the environmental state of
Lake Winnipeg. The Liberals also pledged to provide immediate funding for rapid transit in Winnipeg, phase out the provincial payroll tax while reducing property taxes by as much as 30%, and introduce a new police unit to protect children from sexual exploitation. The party also stressed an environmentally conscious image, purchasing carbon credits to run a carbon-neutral campaign. Gerrard and Lamoureux were again returned to the legislature, but no other Liberals were elected and the party's popular vote slipped again to just under 12.5%.
2017 After being re-elected in 2011, Gerrard resigned as leader and was replaced by
Rana Bokhari. He was re-elected in 2016. Gerrard ran for leader again in 2017, but placed third. He was re-elected in 2019.
2023 The
2023 campaign was dominated by the ailing healthcare system, affordability, and multiple social issues such as
parental rights and
MMIW. The governing Progressive Conservatives were very unpopular throughout the
COVID-19 pandemic, which lead to the resignation of premier
Brian Pallister in 2021 and his subsequent replacement as premier by then health minister
Heather Stefanson. The NDP, led by
Wab Kinew, which had led in the polls for more than two years in the lead up to the election, specifically targeted Liberal voters to vote strategically and prevent
vote splitting on the left. In River Heights, NDP targeting made this a more difficult campaign for Gerrard than in elections prior. Running against Gerrard for the NDP was
Mike Moroz, a local teacher who had become a prominent activist against the provincial education Bill 64 in 2021. On election night, Moroz defeated Gerrard by roughly 6% in the riding, as the NDP would also go on to win a majority government. The result was seen as a major upset, considering the past tilt the riding had towards the Liberals and Gerrard's personal popularity in the riding. Gerrard said in interview after his defeat that he got "caught in an orange wave" with strategic voting and anger towards the governing Conservatives denying him another term. Liberal leader
Dougald Lamont also lost his re-election bid in
St. Boniface, part of an overall poor result for the Liberals.
Cindy Lamoureux was the lone Liberal MLA elected in 2023, in which she was re-elected in the riding of
Tyndall Park. Gerrard was the longest-serving incumbent MLA to lose re-election in 2023, and at the time was tied with PC MLA
Ron Schuler as the second longest-serving MLA in Manitoba. (The longest-serving MLA at the end of the
42nd Manitoba Legislature, outgoing
Legislative Assembly speaker Myrna Driedger, retired.)
Issues Health care Gerrard was involved with health issues throughout his time in the legislature. In 2001, he protested the Doer government's decision to close an outpatient pharmacy at the Winnipeg Health Sciences Centre by bringing several families of child cancer patients to the legislature to confront the health minister. He later called for changes to Manitoba's adult heart surgery program, after figures obtained through a freedom of information request showed an increasing number of fatalities. Gerrard wrote a
Winnipeg Free Press column criticizing the Doer government for health-care delays in 2005, and later argued that personal health information should be made more easily accessible to patients and their families. He released a detailed document promoting change in Manitoba's health system in September 2007, highlighted by a call to make regional health authorities more accountable to citizens.
Agriculture and environment Shortly after the 1999 election, Gerrard took part in an all-party delegation to
Ottawa to lobby the federal government for a cash bailout for struggling western farmers. In early 2004, Gerrard wrote a guest column in the
Winnipeg Free Press calling on the federal government to test every beef and dairy cow over thirty months for
bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE). This recommendation was made during a significant decline in the Canadian cattle market, after the discovery of a BSE-infected cow in
Alberta caused the United States to block all Canadian cattle. Also in 2004, Gerrard accused the Doer government of undermining its water-quality legislation by reducing funds for key programs.
Social issues Gerrard holds liberal views on social issues. He pressured the Doer government to legalize
adoption rights for same-sex couples in 2001, one year before a comprehensive bill including adoption rights was passed by the legislature. Gerrard took part in the Winnipeg Harvest Poverty Challenge in late 2002, and attempted to live for a full week on only $20. The challenge was meant to draw attention to the difficulties faced by Manitoba's lowest-income residents, living on social assistance. In 2003, Gerrard supported calls for a provincial smoking ban in workplaces and enclosed public spaces.
Other issues In early 2005, Gerrard wrote that the Doer government had not taken proper steps to regulate the province's burgeoning internet pharmaceutical industry. This industry was popular with American customers, and Gerrard's column was written at a time when the federal government was seeking to impose greater control over the sector. In April 2007, Gerrard introduced a
private member's bill entitled the Apology Act, to make apologies inadmissible in court as proof of liability or guilt. The bill was modeled after similar legislation in
British Columbia, and was intended to allow medical professionals to apologize to patients without risking legal charges. It was passed into law with government support in November 2007, and formally took effect in February 2008. Gerrard has also called for a public inquiry into the New Democratic Party government's alleged role in failing to prevent the financial collapse of the
Crocus Investment Fund. Following the 2007 election, he took part in an all-party delegation to Ottawa to argue for increased penalties against gang-related criminals and young car thieves. He has also called for a public review of appointees to the
Manitoba Hydro Board, and requested a
plebiscite on the location of a power line from northern to southern Manitoba. In October 2007, he introduced a bill to ban retailers from using
plastic bags by 2009. He also criticized the Doer government's decision to build a
Manitoba Hydro power line on the west side of
Lake Winnipeg, and called for the public to be directly consulted on the issue through non-binding referendums. He called for a provincial moratorium on
taser use in 2007, following increased concerns about its safety.
Other Despite his background as a Chrétien supporter, Gerrard was reported to have endorsed
Paul Martin's bid for the federal Liberal Party leadership in
2003. He supported
Gerard Kennedy's bid in
2006. Gerrard released a history of the Manitoba Liberal Party in 2006, entitled
Battling for a Better Manitoba. A
Winnipeg Free Press reviewer described the book as "a generally readable—though sloppy—account of one of the three provincial parties", adding that the book "perhaps should not have been published in its current state". ==Electoral record==