Critics have charged Ewell with focusing obsessively on "
body counts" during the Vietnam War, causing his subordinates to inflate their numbers in an effort to demonstrate success by counting civilian dead as enemy combatants and committing
atrocities.
David Hackworth, author of ''Steel my Soldiers' Hearts'', was critical of Ewell's performance. Hackworth, who served in the 9th Division during the Vietnam War, wrote that in 1968 and 1969 the division was credited with killing 20,000 enemy, yet recovered only 2,000 weapons, suggesting that the numbers of enemy dead were inflated.
John Paul Vann estimated that of those killed in the Delta were, "at least 30 percent were noncombatants". According to Hackworth, Ewell's focus on body counts earned him the nickname the "Butcher of the Delta" from members of the 9th Division. During Speedy Express, the 9th Division claimed an official enemy body count of 10,899 enemies killed but only 748 weapons captured. A 1972
Inspector General report concluded that "While there appears to be no means of determining the precise number of civilian casualties incurred by US forces during Operation Speedy Express, it would appear that the extent of these casualties was indeed substantial, and that a fairly solid case can be constructed to show that civilian casualties may have amounted to several thousand (between 5,000 and 7,000)." In a 2008 article in
The Nation, reporter
Nick Turse, references a VC report released in December 1969, which stated that during the operation between 1 December 1968, and 1 April 1969, the US military "mopped up many areas, slaughtering 3,000 people, mostly old folks, women and children, and destroying thousands of houses, hundreds of hectares of fields and orchards." In 1974, Ewell and
Ira A. Hunt Jr., a major general who had served as Ewell's Chief of Staff in the 9th Division, authored
Sharpening the Combat Edge. In their book, Ewell and Hunt argued that the allegations of obsession with the body count were unfounded, and that their effort to inflict maximum damage had "unbrutalized" the war for civilians in South Vietnam. Ewell and Hunt's views are countered in
Nick Turse's book,
Kill Anything That Moves: The Real American War in Vietnam. Turse argues that Ewell's tactics amounted to war crimes and asserts that a coverup of Speedy Express went to the top of American decision-making in Vietnam. Turse argues that most accounts attempt to minimize the viciousness and unethical behavior shown by some American commanders and soldiers in Vietnam. ==Awards==