Synopsis The story concerns the seven Hook children, who decide not to report their mother's death for fear of being separated and sent to an orphanage. Instead they bury her in the back garden, pretending to the outside world that she is ill and confined to her room. Their problems begin when curious officials make inquiries, and well-meaning neighbours offer assistance. The children have begun quarrelling when an enigmatic stranger appears, claiming to be their father.
Critical reception Gloag's first novel was an unexpected success and launched him onto the 1960s literary scene.
Our Mother’s House received high praise from many prominent critics.
Evelyn Waugh read it “with keen pleasure and admiration”.
Christopher Fry says the novel “drew me into its world from the first page and held me there ... a penetrating and touching story, which at every point touches on even more than it speaks”.
The London Magazine compares the work to
William Golding’s
Lord of the Flies and says it “achieves explosive effects with seemingly unpromising material”.
Film version Film director
Jack Clayton, who had previously directed
Room at the Top, got to hear about Gloag's novel from his friend, Canadian writer
Mordecai Richler, and he found it “instantly fascinating”. The film version of
Our Mother’s House was produced by
MGM and
Filmways and released in 1967.
Dirk Bogarde played the father, Charlie Hook,
Yootha Joyce played cleaning lady Mrs Quayle, and
Mark Lester played Jiminee, one of the younger boys. Though a commercial failure, the film was well reviewed by
Roger Ebert, who noted the Gothic elements, such as the bleak rundown house and attempts to commune with the spirit world, together with the parallels to
Lord of the Flies. He praises the ensemble of child actors, saying “no adult actor can hope to hold his own against their innocent blue eyes”. Dirk Bogarde received a BAFTA nomination and described working on the project as one of happiest experiences of his career. Child star Mark Lester went on to achieve huge fame a year later with the titular role in the film musical
Oliver! Controversy over similarities to Ian McEwan’s The Cement Garden When
Ian McEwan’s
The Cement Garden was published in 1978, some reviewers noted remarkable similarities between that novel and
Our Mother’s House, and this issue resurfaced in 2006 when McEwan was again accused of copying passages from
Lucilla Andrews’s memoir
No Time for Romance – for the wartime hospital sections of his novel
Atonement.
The Cement Garden and
Our Mother’s House do share common themes and plot strands. Both involve a group of mixed-aged children who conceal their mother’s death and inter her corpse within the family home, and then attempt to carry on normally as best they can. In both works there is a Gothic atmosphere of increasing strangeness, decay and unraveling, which is evocative of the children-only world of
Lord of the Flies. And both plots reach their denouements through the arrival of older male characters who figure out what is really going on. McEwan himself denied the charge of plagiarism, claiming he was unaware of
Our Mother’s House. == Novels mid-1960s and 70s ==