Season 1 Jurors •
Ronald Gladden as himself (Juror #6), a solar contractor from San Diego who serves as the jury foreperson and is the only person unaware that the entire trial is a staged hoax. •
James Marsden as himself (Juror #14), an alternate juror who portrays a "heightened," entitled, and self-absorbed parody of his real-life Hollywood persona. •
Mekki Leeper as Noah Price (Juror #11), a socially awkward rideshare driver who misses a long-planned vacation with his girlfriend to serve on the jury. • Edy Modica as Jeannie Abruzzo (Juror #4), a boisterous and flirtatious juror who develops a strong, persistent romantic attraction to Noah during the trial. • Ishmel Sahid as Lonnie Coleman (Juror #13), an "unproblematic" alternate juror who joins the main jury after Juror #7 is injured and released from the trial. • David Brown as Todd Gregory (Juror #2), a socially awkward inventor with an interest in cybernetics who wears his "chair pants" invention to the courtroom. • Cassandra Blair as Vanessa Jenkins (Juror #8), a self-professed true crime aficionado and "Reddit Bureau of Investigations" member who acts as the jury's lead conspiracy theorist. • Maria Russell as Inez De Leon (Juror #10), an ambitious "boss babe" who fails to become foreperson but takes charge of the jury's lunch orders and social outings. •
Kirk Fox as Pat McCurdy (Juror #1), a regular juror who works as a commercial driving instructor for the DMV. • Susan Berger as Barbara Goldstein (Juror #5), a retired woman who frequently falls asleep during the courtroom proceedings. • Ross Kimball as Ross Kubiak (Juror #12), an affable middle school teacher who is going through a difficult separation from his wife. • Pramode Kumar as Ravi Chattapodhyay (Juror #3), a sweet-natured and soft-spoken juror. • Ron Song as Ken Hyun (Juror #9), a soft-spoken and slow-talking business owner who claims to manage two gumball machines. • Brandon Loeser as Tim Smith (Juror #7), a juror who is dismissed early in the trial after sustaining an injury that requires him to be hospitalized.
Other •
Alan Barinholtz as Judge Alan Rosen, the presiding judge of the trial who is nearing retirement & frequently manages the courtroom's eccentricities. •
Rashida Olayiwola as Officer Nikki Wilder, the primary bailiff for the trial who maintains order in the courtroom and interacts frequently with the jurors. • Whitney Rice as Jacquiline Hilgrove, the wealthy and self-described "relatable" plaintiff who owns the boutique business, Cinnamon and Sparrow. • Ben Seaward as Trevor Morris, the defendant and Cinnamon and Sparrow employee who is accused by Hilgrove of causing significant harm to the business. • Trisha LaFache as Debra LaSeur, the plaintiff's attorney • Evan Williams as Shaun Sanders, the lead defense attorney for Trevor Morris, portrayed by a real-life writer from the show's production team. • Kerry O'Neill as Officer Christine Sugalski, a friendly court security officer who bonds with the jurors and assists Noah in monitoring his girlfriend's social media activity during the trial. • Peter Hulne as Randy "Cody" Schiller, the shift supervisor at Cinnamon and Sparrow who appears as a key witness for the plaintiff. •
Lisa Gilroy as Genevieve Telford-Warren, a multi-talented social media brand ambassador and "pampered" Instagram influencer who serves as a witness for the plaintiff.
Season 2: Company Retreat • Anthony Norman as himself, a 25 year old from Nashville and the only real person in the show, he is a temporary assistant at the fictional Rockin' Grandma's Hot Sauce company who believes he is being filmed for a documentary. • Blair Beeken as Marjorie Lee, the activities manager and owner of Oak Canyon Ranch, the site of the company's annual retreat. • Alex Bonifer as Dougie Womack Jr., the well-meaning but directionless son of the company's CEO, who is preparing to inherit and lead Rockin' Grandma's Hot Sauce. • Warren Burke as Steve Mosley, a high-achieving sales and marketing representative at Rockin' Grandma's Hot Sauce. • LaNisa Renee Frederick as Jackie Griffin, the distribution and logistics manager at Rockin' Grandma's Hot Sauce and a mother of three who is eager to spend time away from her children. • Jerry Hauck as Doug Womack, the retiring CEO and founder of Rockin' Grandma's Hot Sauce. • Erica Hernandez as Kate Martinez, the sales and marketing manager at Rockin' Grandma's Hot Sauce. •
Stephanie Hodge as Helen Schaffer, the cynical accountant at Rockin' Grandma's Hot Sauce. •
Rachel Kaly as Claire Coleman, a remote IT technician and web designer for Rockin' Grandma's who is socially awkward. • Rob Lathan as "Other" Anthony Gwinn, the sourcing manager at Rockin' Grandma's, often referred to as "Other" Anthony. • Emily Pendergast as Amy Patterson, the customer relations manager at Rockin' Grandma's and a devoted fan of Taylor Swift. • Marc-Sully Saint-Fleur as PJ Green, the receptionist at Rockin' Grandma's who maintains an aspiring side career as a "snack influencer". • Jim Woods as Jimmy Weber, the warehouse manager at Rockin' Grandma's. • Wendy Braun as Elizabeth Prescott, the professional head of Triukas, a private equity group. • Ryan Perez as Kevin Gomez, the head of human resources at Rockin' Grandma's. •
Lisa Gilroy as Christine Westbrook-Clark • Brian Patrick Farrell as Brian DeCoy • Katy Colloton as Teri Braun •
Dan Perrault as Dan P. • Roni Lee as Rockin' Grandma •
Nicholas Rutherford as Cole, a realtor who has left behind a personal item at the retreat • Ryan Vukelich as himself ==Episodes==