2019 trials Donawa was not selected to take part in the 2019
MLS Combine after struggling through an injury-ridden senior season at Dartmouth. He went on trial at
Scottish Premiership club
Aberdeen during December, and although he "definitely got good feedback" was not signed by the club. On 14 January 2019,
Columbus Crew SC drafted Donawa with the 66th overall pick in the
2019 MLS SuperDraft. He joined the club for preseason as an unsigned draft pick, but was released midway through camp without earning a contract. Following his release, Donawa went on an unsuccessful trial with
USL Championship club
Pittsburgh Riverhounds SC. He continued his search for a club following the
2019 CONCACAF Gold Cup, moving to England and going on trial with
National League North side
Darlington. Donawa impressed manager
Alun Armstrong during his trial, tallying a goal in a
friendly against
Northallerton Town while being described as "a game-changer" and "as good as gold".
Darlington After impressing during his trial with
Darlington, Donawa was offered a deal for the
2019–20 season. He joined fellow Bermudian international
Osagi Bascome with the Quakers. He made his first start two weeks later in a 2–0 win at home to
Southport, showing his pace on the left wing before being switched to right
wing-back after a defensive injury. Donawa's first National League North goal was a late winner in Darlington's first away win of the season, against
Alfreton Town. He continued as a regular in matchday squad, apart from when required for international duty, although became frustrated at being used as an impact substitute rather than in the starting eleven. According to the
Northern Echo review, Donawa "married electric pace with impressive aerial ability to score nine goals in his debut season", which made him the team's second highest scorer. and added another two goals from five matches before leaving the club in October 2020.
Solihull Moors On 27 October 2020, Donawa signed for
Solihull Moors of the fifth-tier
National League. The fee was undisclosed, but was understood by
North East Sports News to be £15,000 plus add-ons. He made his debut four days later as a second-half substitute in a 3–1 defeat away to
Maidenhead United. He was one of four players to be offered a new contract at the end of the
2022–23 season.
Altrincham Donawa signed for
Altrincham on 23 June 2023, becoming the club's seventh signing ahead of the
2023–24 National League season. He was a matchday regular in the early months of the season,
Brackley Town On 26 November 2024, Donawa joined National League North side
Brackley Town.
Hereford On 2 January 2026, Donawa was released from his contract with Brackley and signed for National League North club
Hereford, joining at the same time as fellow Bermudan international Keziah Martin. In April 2026, he left the club to return to his native Bermuda with his family. ==International career==