BuddyTV's senior writer John Kubieck was shocked by Lilith's debut in "Jus in Bello", specifically by the revelation that she appears as a little girl. Tina Charles of
TV Guide opined that the decision to portray Lilith as a child played to the show's strength of "creating kids that are freakin' scary", but was surprised by the departure from the normal demonic eye color in Lilith's white eyes, wondering at its implications for the character. Overall, she deemed Lilith's introduction one of the highlights of the episode. Despite the change in actresses between
Rachel Pattee and
Sierra McCormick from "Jus in Bello" to "No Rest for the Wicked", Charles felt that "the results were still as creepy". Sandrine Sahakians, Editor-in-Chief for
TV Equals, agreed, writing that, "the scene where she comes out with her dress all full of blood...was one of the freakiest scenes ever." In her review of "The Monster at the End of the Book", Sahakians was very surprised by how frightened Lilith seemed to be of her fate, musing that the character was "not as invincible as we once thought". She also found it "interesting" that, while Lilith was immune to Sam's powers, Sam was immune to Lilith's. Regarding Lilith's depiction in "
No Rest for the Wicked", Don Williams of
BuddyTV deemed her "one extremely scary little girl". He wrote, "As sad as I was to see [Ruby] taken over by Lilith, it was yet another chilling demonstration of how powerful the new demon leader is. Watching the little girl snap her grandpa's neck just for kicks was creepy enough, but seeing her take over Ruby's body was truly frightening. It's one of the many disturbing moments in 'No Rest for the Wicked' that helps to make it so unforgettable", concluding that, "By the end of the episode, it's obvious that the Winchesters have never faced any demon as powerful as adorable little Lilith." Karla Peterson of the
San Diego Union-Tribune also remarked on Lilith's possession of Ruby's host, when she noted that
Katie Cassidy did a "terrific job of acting like a completely different character is inside her body". Likewise, Diana Steenbergen of
IGN found it "nice to see Katie Cassidy have a chance to act so differently", and believed that "Lilith and her little girl mannerisms in Ruby's body were far more chilling, and interesting, than Ruby's tough chick persona ever has been". On McCormick's reprisal of her role as Lilith in "Yellow Fever", Steenbergen was similarly positive towards Lilith's characterization, writing that, "Lillith
[sic] as a little girl in a cute pink dress being the embodiment of evil is still creepy." She felt that the revelation in "When the Levee Breaks" that Lilith eats babies detracted from an otherwise well-written episode, as she believed that Lilith's evil had already been so firmly established that adding in a scene implying the murder of infants was "pointless". Brett Love of
TV Squad gave a mixed review on how the character was used in "No Rest for the Wicked". He enjoyed Lilith's storyline and that she "served as the catalyst for some great Ruby bits" throughout the season, but felt that the shortened season did not allow the proper build up for her character. He also did not like the change in Lilith's host, explaining, "each [body jump] takes away a little bit from the character...Especially if the demon in question keeps jumping into cute little girls". Although McCormick impressed him, he posited that "when it comes to menacing and scary, she's no
Fredric Lehne" (Azazel). Overall, he felt "a little disappointed". Fans have responded positively to Lilith. In 2009, she was voted the third-greatest
Supernatural villain in an online poll conducted by
BuddyTV, placing her below fellow demons Azazel (the winner of the poll) and Alastair. ==References==