On the
review aggregator website
Rotten Tomatoes, the film holds an approval rating of based on reviews, with an average rating of . The website's critics consensus reads, "
Fear Street Part One: 1994 kicks off the trilogy in promising fashion, honoring the source material with plenty of retro slasher appeal." On
Metacritic, the film has a weighted average score of 67 out of 100 based on 20 critic reviews, indicating "generally favorable" reviews. Alison Willmore, writing for
Vulture, described the film as "a nasty, effective slasher", and wrote: "Where
Get Out or
The Babadook used horror to explore the razor-toothed hunger of white liberal (supposed) allies and the terror of feeling unable to trust your own mental state, plenty of other titles end up just pinning themselves to larger concepts in ways that range from clumsily obvious to grossly cynical. But
1994 feels untethered from these obligations." She noted some similarities to the 2014 horror film
It Follows, but added: "Janiak's film is saltier, soapier, and more pragmatic—it has sequels to dole out, after all." Lovia Gyarkye of
The Hollywood Reporter wrote: "While it probably won't have you triple checking the locks on your door, it's likely to keep you entertained enough to come back for more", and added: "Even if the conventions are familiar, the film manages to excite thanks to an impressive array of young talent, an appropriately suspenseful score and soundtrack, and a heavy dose of '90s nostalgia." She concluded: "
Fear Street Part 1 is fun, and hits its marks with sufficient flair—I'm certainly motivated to see the next two installments—but sometimes the key to subversion is in the details." A.A. Dowd of
The A.V. Club was more critical of the film. In his review, he gave it a grade of C+, describing the killers as being "awfully generic, like the attractions of a slasher parody or one of the more forgettable
Halloween knockoffs", and writing: "Slashers used to take a beating for their supposed puritanical politics, but the teens here are as clean and upstanding as they are "likable": A mid-film sex scene in a locker room might be the most wholesome in the history of this disreputable genre". He concluded: "Forget the middle-aged fans it might irk. Don't today's kids deserve some trash of their own, instead of a tasteful substitution?" Barry Hertz of
The Globe and Mail wrote: "while Janiak is able to easily tick off the hallmarks of the genre, and perhaps convince those actually alive in the nineties that the entire decade must have been backlit in aggressive neon, her film doesn't quite scream (or
Scream) out for two more films' worth of context", and criticized the film's story. However, he concluded that "given that theatres are still closed in
Ontario and I find myself increasingly brain-drained come evening, I'm willing to walk down Janiak's path. Even if
Fear Street ends up becoming a dead end." The film ranks on Rotten Tomatoes' Best Horror Movies of 2021. ==Sequels==