Theatrical run Without a proper release across the U.S.,
The Killing performed poorly at the box office. In spite of a last-minute promotion as a second feature to
Bandido! it failed to turn a profit. But it was critically acclaimed, and appeared on several critics' top-ten lists for 1956.
Time wrongly predicted that it would "make a killing at the cash booths"—asserting that Kubrick "has shown more audacity with dialogue and camera than Hollywood has seen since the obstreperous
Orson Welles went riding out of town on an exhibitors' poll"—as the film recorded a loss of $130,000.
Critical response New York Times film critic A. H. Weiler wrote, "Though
The Killing is composed of familiar ingredients and it calls for fuller explanations, it evolves as a fairly diverting melodrama. ... Aficionados of the sport of kings will discover that Mr. Kubrick's cameras have captured some colorful shots of the ponies at
Bay Meadows track. Other observers should find
The Killing an engrossing little adventure."
Variety liked the acting and wrote, "This story of a $2 million race track holdup and steps leading up to the robbery, occasionally told in a documentary style which at first tends to be somewhat confusing, soon settles into a tense and suspenseful vein which carries through to an unexpected and ironic windup ... Hayden socks over a restrained characterization, and Cook is a particular standout. Windsor is particularly good, as she digs the plan out of her husband and reveals it to her boyfriend." Kubrick and Harris thought the positive critical reception had made their presence known in Hollywood, but
Max Youngstein of United Artists still considered them "not far from the bottom" of the pool of new talent at the time.
Dore Schary of
Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer was impressed with the film, and offered the duo $75,000 to write, direct and produce another, which became
Paths of Glory.
The Killing has gained a cult following, among other Kubrick films. In 1998,
Jonathan Rosenbaum of the
Chicago Reader included the film in his unranked list of the best American films not included on the
AFI Top 100. In 1999, film critic Mike Emery wrote, "Kubrick's camerawork was well on the way to finding the fluid style of his later work, and the sparse, low-budget circumstances give the film a raw, urgent sort of look. As good as the story and direction are, though, the true strength of
The Killing lies in the characters and characterizations." The same year, director
Peter Bogdanovich wrote in
The New York Times that while
The Killing did not make money, it, along with
Paths of Glory, established "Kubrick's reputation as a budding genius among critics and studio executives." In 2012,
Roger Ebert added
The Killing to his list of "Great Movies". In his opening remarks, Ebert writes, "Stanley Kubrick considered
The Killing (1956) to be his first mature feature, after a couple of short warm-ups. He was 28 when it was released, having already been an obsessed chess player, a photographer for
Look magazine and a director of
March of Time newsreels. It's tempting to search here for themes and a style he would return to in his later masterpieces, but few directors seemed so determined to make every one of his films an individual, free-standing work. Seeing it without his credit, would you guess it was by Kubrick? Would you connect
Dr. Strangelove with
Barry Lyndon?"
Awards Nominations •
BAFTA Film Award, Best Film from any Source, USA; 1957.
Influence Quentin Tarantino has said that this film was an influence on
Reservoir Dogs, that he thought of that film as "my
Killing, my take on that kind of heist movie." ==Home media==