WNBA Chicago Sky (2009) In the
2009 WNBA draft, the Chicago Sky selected Toliver with the third pick. In her rookie season with the Sky, Toliver came off the bench averaging 7.6 points per game in 27 games and ranked second in the league in three-point shooting. As a rookie, Toliver signed an endorsement deal with
Nike.
Los Angeles Sparks (2010–2016) Toliver was traded to the
Los Angeles Sparks just before the start of the 2010 season in exchange for a 2011 second round draft pick. In her first season with the Sparks, Toliver was the backup point guard on the roster behind
Ticha Penicheiro. She averaged 8.6 points per game in 34 games. In the 2012 season with the departure of Penicheiro, Toliver became the starting point guard for the Sparks and had a breakout season. In the month of May, Toliver hit a game winning 3-pointer at the buzzer against the
Tulsa Shock. She was the Western Conference Player of the Month for August, averaged a career-high 17.5 points per game, was ranked 9th in three-point field goal percentage, was named to the All-WNBA Second Team and won the
WNBA Most Improved Player Award. Her offensive performance continued in the playoffs, where she averaged 20 points per game in 4 games. The Sparks were eventually eliminated in a 2-game sweep by the
Minnesota Lynx in the conference finals. In 2013, Toliver re-signed with the Sparks to a multi-year deal once her rookie contract with the Sky expired. With the acquisition of
Lindsey Harding, Toliver became the starting shooting guard for the Sparks. During the season, Toliver was named a WNBA All-Star for the first time in her career, while averaging 14.1 points per game in all 34 games. in 2017 During the 2015 season, Toliver was assigned back to the point guard position after Harding was waived. In a regular season game win against the
Tulsa Shock, Toliver set a Sparks scoring franchise record with 43 points, surpassing
Lisa Leslie's 41 points. She finished the season averaging 12.4 points per game. In the 2016 season, the Sparks finished 26–8 with the second seed, and defeated Chicago 3–1 in the conference semi-finals. Toliver was ranked 4th in three-point field goal percentage while averaging 13.2 points per game during the regular season. On June 24, 2016, Toliver scored a season-high 25 points along with 7 three-pointers in a regular season game win against the Minnesota Lynx. With a supporting cast of
Candace Parker and
Nneka Ogwumike, Toliver won her first WNBA championship with the Sparks as they defeated the Minnesota Lynx 3–2 in the Finals. Toliver is currently the Sparks franchise leader in three-point field goal percentage and free-throw percentage.
Washington Mystics (2017–2019) In February 2017, Toliver signed with the
Washington Mystics in free agency. On May 14, 2017, Toliver made her debut for the Mystics, scoring 8 points along with 4 assists in an 89–74 victory over the
San Antonio Stars. On July 19, 2017, with
Tayler Hill and
Elena Delle Donne sidelined with injuries, Toliver scored a season-high 29 points while hitting 7 three-pointers in a 100–96 overtime win against the
Atlanta Dream after coming back from a 21-point deficit. The Mystics secured a playoff berth as the number 6 seed in the league with an 18–16 record. In the first-round elimination game, the Mystics defeated the
Dallas Wings 86–76 with Toliver scoring 16 points. In the second round elimination game, the Mystics advanced to the semi-finals after defeating the number 3-seeded
New York Liberty, 82–68, making it the first time in franchise history where the Mystics had advanced past the second round. Toliver scored 32 points in the win while scoring 17 of them in the third quarter and made a WNBA-record 9 three-pointers. In the semi-finals, the Mystics were defeated by the Minnesota Lynx in a 3-game sweep. On May 30, 2018, Toliver scored a season-high 30 points in a 103–95 victory against the
Phoenix Mercury. Later on in the 2018 season, Toliver was voted into the
2018 WNBA All-Star Game, making it her second all-star appearance. Toliver finished off the season with 13.9 points per game with career-highs in free throw shooting and minutes. The Mystics finished as the number three seed in the league with a 22–12 record, receiving a bye to the second round elimination game. They defeated the Los Angeles Sparks 96–64, advancing to the semi-finals for the second year in a row. In the semi-finals, they defeated the Atlanta Dream in five games, advancing to the WNBA Finals for the first time in franchise history. The Mystics were swept in the Finals against the Seattle Storm. On July 24, 2019, Toliver scored a season-high 32 points in a 79–71 victory over the Minnesota Lynx. Toliver was voted into the WNBA All-Star game, making it her third all-star appearance. A few weeks after the all-star break, Toliver injured her knee and missed the rest of the regular season. Despite her injury, the Mystics finished as the number 1 seed in the league with a 26–8 record, receiving a double-bye to the semi-finals. Toliver returned from injury in the playoffs for Game 1 off the bench against the
Las Vegas Aces in the semi-finals, helping the Mystics gain a 1–0 lead. She continued to be on minutes restriction for the duration of the series until Game 4. The Mystics defeated the Aces 3–1 to advance to the WNBA Finals for the second year in a row. Against the
Connecticut Sun, the Mystics won the WNBA Finals in five games, earning Toliver her second WNBA championship.
Second stint with Sparks (2020–2022) In February 2020, Toliver returned to the Sparks in free agency on a three-year deal. However, in June 2020, she would opt to not play in the
2020 WNBA season due to health concerns surrounding the
COVID-19 pandemic. Without Toliver, the Sparks finished as the number 3 seed with a 15–7 record in the shortened 22-game season, receiving a bye to the second round, but would end up getting eliminated by the Connecticut Sun in the second round elimination game.
International career In the 2009–10 off-season, Toliver spent the first portion of the off-season in
Israel playing for Raanana Hertzeliya. In the second portion of the off-season, Toliver played in
Hungary for
MKB Euroleasing Sopron. In the 2010–11 off-season, Toliver played in
Turkey for Samsun Canik Belediyesi. From 2011 to 2014, Toliver played three off-seasons in
Russia for
Dynamo Moscow, winning back-to-back championships with the team in 2013 and 2014. Toliver was a member of the
Slovakia women's national basketball team in the
EuroBasket Women 2015 qualification tournament in 2014 after receiving her Slovak citizenship. The team finished first place in Group A to qualify for the
EuroBasket Women 2015 tournament, where they finished 9th place with a 3–4 record, missing out on a spot in the
Olympic qualifying tournament for the
2016 Summer Olympics. From 2014 to 2016, Toliver has played for
UMMC Ekaterinburg in Russia for two off-seasons and had won back-to-back championships with the team in 2015 and 2016. Toliver played with teammate,
Candace Parker in her first-offseason with the team. As of August 2016, Toliver had re-signed with UMMC Ekaterinburg for the 2016–17 off-season and won her third consecutive championship with the team. In 2017, Toliver re-signed again with UMMC Ekaterinburg for the 2017–18 off-season and won her fourth consecutive Russian League championship with the team. == Coaching career ==