Throwing Muses and early solo work Throwing Muses was formed in 1981 when Hersh and Donelly were freshmen in high school. Friends from school, including Elaine Adamedes, Becca Blumen, Leslie Langston and
David Narcizo, were part of the group with Narcizo (and in the beginning, Langston) becoming a long-term member. Hersh initially wrote and sang most of Throwing Muses' songs, often in changing tempos. Donelly contributed songs and lead vocals. Hersh attended
Salve Regina University in Newport, majoring in archetypal psychology and philosophy, but dropped out shortly before graduating to establish the band in
Boston where they had been playing on weekends. The Throwing Muses were signed to
4AD, the first American group to be signed on the British label, and released the EP
Chains Changed in 1987. Two releases followed, the mini-LP
The Fat Skier and the album
House Tornado. The 4AD Throwing Muses biography describes its sound at the time as "joining the dots between elliptical
post-punk, harmonious folk jangle and
rockabilly thunder without ever settling into standard genre patterns." For the Throwing Muses 1986 UK tour, the Boston-based
Pixies, embarking on their first European tour, was the opening band. The band signed a U.S. deal with
Sire/
Reprise Records in 1987 and began touring the U.S. and Europe while recording albums, with Hersh writing most of the songs. The band became a trio when Donelly left the group after 1991's
The Real Ramona. In 1994, Hersh began a solo career on Sire/Reprise and 4AD as an acoustic performer, beginning with
Hips and Makers, an album sparsely arranged around her vocals, guitar, and a cellist, in contrast to the volatile, electric sound of her band work.
Michael Stipe of
R.E.M. made an appearance on this first solo album. After receiving some airplay and major media coverage for the Throwing Muses album
University in 1995, Hersh moved to
Rykodisc for the band's 1996 album,
Limbo, and released her solo album,
Strange Angels, in 1998. To better control her career and the distribution of her recorded material, she created the ThrowingMusic label with then-husband and manager Billy O'Connell in 1996. That enabled her to co-release some of her projects, including an ongoing download-subscription service called Works in Progress (WIP) for releases available through the label's website. Throwing Muses functions as a noncommercial musical enterprise, focusing on touring over record sales and airplay. In a 2014 interview, Hersh said, "As far as I'm concerned, music is not a commodity. It's something that people have earned by being human. They have a right to hear it, and a right to share it, as they always have in churches and parties. That's how music happens."
NPR described Hersh's "emotional and raw" pop songs as both "accessible and off-kilter." Concurrently she launched
CASH Music, a subscription-based, direct-to-consumer website, that was formed along with fellow musician
Donita Sparks. Fans can become "Strange Angels" and subscribe to her output to receive albums and print releases, downloadable content, and guest spots for live shows–packages ranging from $30 per quarter to $5,000 (executive producer credit on her next album) and Hersh was involved in several projects—a second collection of
Appalachian folksongs,
The Shady Circle and a series of new free tracks. The album
Crooked was released as a downloadable album and hardback book containing essays about each track. Throwing Muses reformed in 2013 and released
Purgatory/Paradise, a 32-track album accompanied by a book designed by Narcizo, who works as a graphic designer. The book features photos, artwork and lyrics by Hersh. It was the band's first release in ten years. At that point in her career, Hersh's output was independently released online. She expressed that she wanted a complete break with the music industry, stating, "Because we differ from the recording industry ethically, we had been asked to dumb down our product so many times. I have been asked to act and look like a bimbo so many times and I just decided, 'I'm not going to turn my back on my music. I'm not going to turn my back on women.' We're morally bound to not participate in the traditional recording industry because we disagree with it. So we continue to play music, which has nothing to do with the music business." In October 2016, she released the double album
Wyatt at the Coyote Place and an accompanying book
. Hersh embarked on a tour in support of the album. On June 12, 2018, Hersh announced on her website that she has signed with Fire Records. Her new record,
Possible Dust Clouds, was released on October 5, 2018. She finished recording the album in May of the same year. In February 2020, it was announced that Throwing Muses would release a new album,
Sun Racket, on May 22; the release was delayed to September 4. ==Themes and style==