Album of the Year summarizes critical consensus as an 80 out of 100, based on seven reviews and AnyDecentMusic? scores it a 7.8 out of 10 with five reviews. Writing for
Louder Than War, Nathan Whittle gave the release four out of five bombs, summing up the release as "a wonderful return for Throwing Muses and one that sees them really channeling their best". The editorial staff of
AllMusic also gave the album four out of five stars, with reviewer Heather Phares and stated that, "the sheer density of
Sun Racket makes it something of a grower, but fans will be more than willing to take the time to let these songs sink into them". In
Bust, Michael Levine calls this "a standout moment in this seminal band’s musical canon". Online music platform
Bandcamp highlighted this as Album of the Day, with Mariana Timony summing up that
Sun Racket "has the sense of being poised between the material and the immaterial worlds, one foot in the earthiness of visceral rock music and the other in the magical realm from which springs that rarest of musical gifts: chemistry". Andy Von Pip of
Under the Radar gave the release an 8 out of 10 for having 10 "near-perfect songs". Reviews from British outlets
The Arts Desk,
Mojo, and
musicOMH all assessed
Sun Racket as four out of five stars: for the first, Guy Oddy calls
Sun Racket "floaty and ethereal melodies blend and twist around the raw and the primal to produce something truly magnificent, as Throwing Muses cast a disorientating but wholly satisfying spell with their first album in seven years", followed by Sam Shephard due to the duality of "dark and light, loud and quiet, beautiful and ugly [with] the oppositional forces combin[ing] with powerful effect" for "songs worth revisiting over and over again", and
Mojos Matin Anson praising the diversity of sounds as well and Hersh's willingness to experiment as a songwriter. In
Uncut, Daniel Day Wray gave this release an 8 out of 10 for "seamlessly blend[ing] discordance with harmony". David Taylor of
The London Evening Standard writes that
Sun Racket is "as accomplished as when the band were in their late-Eighties/early-Nineties pomp" and Sean Kitchling of
The Quietus hopes "this album might also serve to bring word of Throwing Muses inspiring music to a new generation". ==Track listing==