The yoga scholar
Andrea Jain states that while pranayama in modern
yoga as exercise consists of synchronising the breath with movements (between
asanas), in ancient texts like the
Bhagavad Gita and the
Yoga Sutras of Patanjali, pranayama meant "complete cessation of breathing", for which she cites Bronkhorst 2007. The
Yoga Sutras state: According to the
scholar-practitioner of yoga
Theos Bernard, the ultimate aim of pranayama is the suspension of breathing, "causing the mind to swoon".
Swami Yogananda writes, "The real meaning of Pranayama, according to Patanjali, the founder of Yoga philosophy, is the gradual cessation of breathing, the discontinuance of inhalation and exhalation". The yoga scholars
James Mallinson and
Mark Singleton write that "pure breath-retention" (without inhalation or exhalation) is the ultimate pranayama practice in later hatha yoga texts. They give as an example the account in the c. 13th century
Dattātreyayogaśāstra of
kevala kumbhaka (breath retention unaccompanied by breathing). They note that this is "the only advanced technique" of breath-control in that text, stating that in it the breath can be held "for as long as one wishes". The
Dattātreyayogaśāstra states that
kevala kumbhaka The 15th century
Hatha Yoga Pradipika states that the
kumbhakas force the breath into the central
sushumna channel (allowing
kundalini to rise and cause
liberation). The 18th century
Gheranda Samhita states that death is impossible when the breath is held in the body. Mallinson and Singleton note that
sahita kumbhaka, the intermediate state which is still accompanied (the meaning of
sahita) by breathing, was described in detail. They write that the
Goraksha Sataka describes four
sahita kumbhakas, and that the
Hatha Yoga Pradipika describes another four. They point out, however, that these supposed
kumbhakas differ in their styles of breathing, giving the example of the buzzing noise made while breathing in
bhramari. ==See also==