Political controversy In July 1964, after the upcoming series had been publicized but before any programs had aired, the right-wing
John Birch Society launched a letter-writing campaign aimed at sponsor Xerox with the goal of suppressing the series. In the Society's bulletin, its national director of public information,
John Rousselot, called for a "flood of 50,000 to 100,000 letters of protest". Although the John Birch Society was unsuccessful in suppressing the series entirely, CBS recognized that "there is, whether we like it or not, a substantial segment of the American population which is opposed to the U.N."
Critics' response The four films that aired received mixed reviews. For the first two films, some critics praised the productions, while others felt that the theme of support for the UN was presented in a heavy-handed, moralistic manner that detracted from the dramatic value.
New York Times critic
Jack Gould wrote a sharply negative review of the series premiere
A Carol for Another Christmas, The second film,
Who Has Seen the Wind?, was considered a "
soap opera" by some critics, with Gould calling it "
Peyton Place on a raft". By the third film, the
screwball comedy Once Upon a Tractor, the promotional information about the UN had been made more subtle, causing at least one critic to complain that this approach was less likely than the previous polemical style to convert viewers opposed to the UN.
Tractor was also criticized for having a weak and unbelievable script. and re-used some Bond film elements in
Poppy. In its television form,
Poppy received good reviews from
UPI television critic Rick DuBrow and
Variety, but was criticized by others as heavy-handed, stereotypical, and "a very long, confusing bore". Its theatrical release version was severely panned by
Time as "another James Bond movie filmed without James Bond, and many will wish it had been filmed without film".
Time further noted that the film was developed "from an idea proposed by author Ian Fleming, who mercifully died before he could see what happened to it." ''
Leonard Maltin's Movie Guide deemed it an "[i]ncredibly bad anti-drug feature", saying that its "[a]cting is downright poor at times." resulting in one win by Eli Wallach for "Outstanding Performance by an Actor in a Supporting Role in a Drama" in The Poppy Is Also a Flower''. In a December 1965
New York Times article discussing the postponement of the planned fifth film due to hostilities in the filming location, Val Adams observed, "Some professional television critics, writing sympathetically of the purpose behind the series, said that theatrically it was dogged by misfortune."
Audience response A Roper poll taken after the first two films were broadcast found that approximately one in five adult Americans had watched at least part of one film. However, following the broadcast of the first three films, an
Associated Press story stated that the series so far had "attracted neither the big audiences nor the critical acclaim that had been anticipated". ==Other films associated with the series==