Brood parasitism Like many members of the genus
Phengaris, large blues are
brood parasites, relying on another insect to raise their young. In this case, the hosts are species of
Myrmica ant. By being physically and chemically similar to
Myrmica ants in their larval stage, and possibly by using other forms of mimicry,
Phengaris caterpillars trick the ants into taking them back to the ant nest. Once there, the caterpillar will either become a predator of the ant larvae, or beg for food by acting like an ant larva in what is known as a "
cuckoo" strategy. The "cuckoo" method is viewed as a more successful strategy, as studies have consistently found more larvae per nest for cuckoo butterfly species than predator butterflies. Through much research, it has been well documented that large blue butterflies act as predators in the host nests.
Host species Early ideas of the
Phengaris-Myrmica relationship resulted in the construction of a linear relationship between one predator and one host. It was proposed that each species of
Phengaris had evolutionarily adapted to prey on one specific species of
Myrmica with the large blue focusing on
M. sabuleti. It was also thought that certain species of
Phengaris were capable of avoiding overcrowding on food plants by detecting high egg loads. Wild thyme is the preferred food plant in the UK and in cooler or more mountainous areas in Europe, marjoram is preferred by populations in warmer areas.
Larva/caterpillar stage After about three weeks, larvae hatch to feed on the seeds and flowers of the plant. The caterpillar will stay in the vicinity of its food plant until its 4th
instar, when it will drop to the ground. Several caterpillar species of
Phengaris, such as
P. rebeli and
P. alcon, will secrete pheromones that are specific to their respective hosts. The purpose of such behaviour is to mimic the pheromones of ant larvae that will become workers in the future. By successfully mimicking ant larvae, the caterpillars are taken back to the host nest and fed by the ants. Originally it was thought that the large blue butterfly behaved differently in that some believed it either secreted a poor pheromone mimic, or did not secrete one at all. The large blue larvae using the cuckoo strategy stay in close quarters with the ants while producing a noise very similar to that of a larval
queen ant. By mimicking a queen, larva are fed by the worker ants and are given preferential treatment over the real ant larvae. Cuckoo strategy users become such high-status members of the nest that the ants will kill their own larvae to feed the caterpillar and will rescue the caterpillar first in the face of danger. Previously it had been thought that only "cuckoo" strategy species used acoustic mimicry.
Cuckoo vs. predatory strategies Scientists remain unsure why there are multiple strategies within the host nest, but studies have been conducted to determine the effectiveness of each. The cuckoo strategy results in six times more butterflies per nest than the predatory strategy. While this seems to indicate a dominance of the cuckoo strategy, there are other factors to consider. Since the cuckoo caterpillars remain in close vicinity of the ants, they must secrete chemicals that are almost identical to the host species in order to survive. This explains why cuckoo strategy users are more likely to be predated by the host colony when adopted by a non-primary host than predatory strategy users. Current data seem to support the idea that cuckoo strategy users depend on a specific species of
Myrmica ant while predatory
Phengaris are more versatile overall but still perform better with a specific species.
The queen effect It has been found that large blue butterflies are three times less likely to survive in nests that have queen ants present. This discovery has been explained with a theory called the "queen effect". In most
Myrmica nests, the queen ant will lay two main batches of eggs, and the females that hatch from these eggs will either become workers or
virgin queens. Whether these females become workers or virgin queens is dependent on the status of the queen in the nest. If the queen dies, worker ants have the largest of the female larvae transition into virgin queens. If the queen is present and healthy, she influences the nurse workers to neglect, starve and bite the female larvae which results in restricted growth and aids in the transition to workers. This indicates that
Phengaris butterflies must maintain a strict balance between mimicking the queen in the presence of workers and appearing to be a worker to avoid the queen. == See also ==