Chuck Taylor from
Billboard called "Love Like This" a "surprisingly bouncy, retro-vibed jam that borrows a tasty riff or two from
Chic's "
Chic Cheer". A nice change of pace for this revered soul balladeer, "Love Like This" also crackles with some smooth guitar work and a vocal that purrs with moist sensuality. Evans sounds like she's having an absolute blast here, and her positive energy is downright contagious.
Ronnie Herel for
Record Mirror Dance Update gave it four out of five, adding, "This is phat and phunky as phuk. [...] Faith smashes a mature vocal over what can only be described as a dope groove. The chorus has hook written all over it and as soon as
Bad Boy decides on when to release it, it has an obvious, in-your-face bullet on its hands. You need this!"
AllMusic editor Jose F. Promis declared "Love Like This" an "irresistible dance/R&B cut." In his review of parent album
Keep the Faith, Ernest Hardy from
Rolling Stone wrote that of "the three midtempo tracks, the best is the first single, "Love Like This"." In 2018,
Billboard ranked the album 43rd on its retrospective The 98 Greatest Songs of 1998: Critics' Picks listing, writing: "As soon as you hear the mesmerizing opening beats, you can't help but rock to what's since become a party, club, and skating-rink mainstay." ==Music video==