According to the
BBC, the 2019 report by the order found that Marcial Maciel had abused at least 60 children, and that another 33 priests of the order abused minors, bringing the total number of children abused by the order since its founding in 1941 to at least 175. One of the first English language public reports of abuse came in 1997 exposing abuse that happened in the 1950s. Juan Vaca and seven other early victims of Maciel "gave graphic accounts" in the
Hartford Courant of how they watched Maciel inject himself with a morphine painkiller in Spain and Rome in the 1950s and finally had to be hospitalized. Cardinal Valerio Valeri received reports "from an older seminarian in Mexico City" and the head of the one Legion high school at the time (Cumbres Institute), who were concerned about Maciel's drug use and "overly affectionate behavior with boys". The superiors of the congregation did not officially inform the rest of the congregation until a year after his death, during which time, they continued to permit an internal culture of revering him as a saint. The Legionaries of Christ eventually acknowledged their founder's "reprehensible and objectively immoral behavior" as head of the congregation. As a result of the scandal, Pope Benedict XVI also removed the vow of charity, which required members to maintain secrecy, impermeability, and refrain from criticism of superiors. After the scandals of Maciel came to light, some priests and seminarians left the congregation. Several schools and centers of formation closed. In 2019, the organization admitted that Father Fernando Martínez Suarez had abused eight minors between 1990 and 1993. A month later, they admitted that members of the organization had sexually abused 175 children between 1941 and 2019. Sixty of those were abused by its founder, some of whom were his own children from several relations. Six of the priests had died, eight had left the priesthood, one left the Congregation, and 18 continued in their posts but had been removed from tasks where they interacted with the public or with children. The 2019 report by the Legion noted that 14 of the 33 priests who abused minors had been victims themselves when they were young, thus highlighting what it called "chains of abuse", where "a victim of a Legionnaire, over time, becomes in turn an aggressor". In 1998, nine men lodged formal charges at the Vatican that Maciel had abused them as youths and young men while studying under him; Maciel was initially investigated by the
Holy See and suspended from his ministry in 2006. In 2009, an
apostolic visitation was ordered by Pope
Benedict XVI and shortly after Cardinal
Velasio De Paolis was delegated to impose "structural changes". In 2014, the five-year renewal process was completed with the approval of amended constitutions; five years later,
Pope Francis referred to the new Constitutions approvingly. On December 21, 2019, the Legionaries of Christ released the "Report 1941-2019 on the Phenomenon of Sexual Abuse of Minors in the Congregation of the Legionaries of Christ from its Founding to the Present Day". According to the report, an internal commission "verified the various accusations of sexual abuse of minors throughout the history of the Congregation of the Legionaries of Christ. It collected the global statistics of cases of abuse by its priests between 1941 and 2019 and included an appendix with the steps taken to prevent future abuse and guarantee safe environments." When the report was released, Father John Connor (then North American territorial director of the LC and later the general director of the Congregation worldwide) released a communication compiling a list of all of the previously released names of Legionaries of Christ who were active in ministry with substantiated sexual abuse allegations in the United States. One month later, Father John again addressed the North American territory in a letter saying, "We must pray that these victims receive the healing they need and that those who are still trying to find the courage to come forward are able to find it. This is an important part of the healing process for victims and it’s important for the Congregation to listen to the experiences of victims so that we can make reparation and be further purified." In his letter, Father John also affirmed that the organization is "committed to transparency about the abuse that has been perpetrated by Legionaries of Christ, to working towards a culture in which all our priests deeply understand the effects of sexual abuse and their role as spiritual fathers dedicated to nourishing God’s people, and to helping those who have been harmed to heal from their wounds." ==Apostolic visitation==