Let It Reign was met with generally favourable reviews from
music critics. At
Metacritic, which assigns a
normalized rating out of 100 to reviews from mainstream publications, the album received an
average score of 67, based on sixteen reviews. The aggregator AnyDecentMusic? has the critical consensus of the album at a 6.5 out of 10, based on thirteen reviews.
Mark Beaumont of
NME praised the album, calling it "the most electric and exuberant record he's made since
Up the Bracket". Caroline Sullivan of
The Guardian stated: "this feels like a placeholder for the forthcoming
Libertines album, but, as placeholders go, it's a stormer".
AllMusic's Heather Phares determined: "
Let It Reigns appealing mix of nostalgia and vitality proves that Barât can not just survive, but thrive outside of the confines of his other, storied band". Lisa Sookraj of
Exclaim! noted: "it's the slower, more "mature" tracks that disappoint here.... Still there's plenty to like on
Let It Reign for Libertines fans missing that
garage rock sound". Jeff Strowe of
PopMatters wrote: "it's an affair that is much more snarling and punkish than solemn and introspective and one that appears to have been a good representation of what he had in mind". In mixed reviews, Lily Moayeri of
Under the Radar declared: "a return to the garage rock that has propelled most of his musical endeavors, the primary thrust of
Let It Reign is guttural. There are, however, tempo and minor style changes along the way that stop the album from being one long string of yells". Dusty Henry of
Consequence stated: "save for the singles, it all feels inconsequential. It plays more like a young band who grew up worshipping
Up the Bracket, rather than identifying with the songwriter who helped forge the sound". Andrzej Lukowski of
Drowned in Sound concluded: "as a warm up exercise for Barât's musical muscles and an honouring of a debt to The Jackals,
Let It Reign is absolutely fine. But Libertines album number three will need to deliver a lot more than this". Phil Mongredien of
The Observer resumed: "for the most part, these songs just sound as if they're being bashed out at a slower tempo". Dan Owens of
DIY gave the album one-out-of-five stars, admitting "
Let It Reigns abrasiveness does little to deflect from its disappointing lack of ambition". ==Track listing==