"Love Takes Time" garnered a positive reception upon its release. Many music critics described the song as beautiful or emotional. Diane Rufer and Ron Fell of the
Gavin Report called it "an awesome ballad of heroic proportions" and
Billboard said Carey surpassed expectations. According to
Cash Box, "Carey keeps things simmering at a low heat, slowly unveiling the power and beauty of her voice."
Record Mirror critic Robin Smith called it "very pretty, very nice, but strangely soulless and cold."
Entertainment Weekly wrote, "With just the softest synthesizer tinkle, a touch of percussion, and what may well have been a borrowed pair of back-porch wind chimes, she made every last listener feel the utter despair of a breakup: "Losing my mind/From this hollow in my heart/Suddenly I’m so incomplete."" In 2015, Est 1997 writer Mario stated that it was an ″
Adult Contemporary ballad″ and that it was "arguably some of the strongest melodies and bridge in Mariah’s catalog." He continued by saying that ″Her vocals are so pure and passionate that every emotion filters through the music and just reaches and warms the heart. It’s the realisation of a universal truth by a young woman who’s still learning to deal with feelings. There’s almost a sense of naivety in the lyrics but, at the same time, the song sounds mature and it’s relatable. That’s a constant in Mariah’s catalog, something that has marked her strength and endurance as a writer." During a review of her 2001
Greatest Hits album in May 2002, Devon Powers of
PopMatters praised the song along with "
I Don't Wanna Cry", calling it "stupendous" and said that ″Her lyrics were exactly what you wanted them to be: simple, memorable, and absolutely true." Stephen Filippelli from Review Stream called the song decent, but mainly criticized the music video for the song. Amanda Dobbins and Lindsay Weber of
Vulture listed "Love Takes Time" at number-nineteen on their list of "Mariah Carey’s 25 Best Singles". OO Cities called the song a "beautiful ballad". ==Accolades==