Stryker's first position was in
Auburn, New York. In 1878 he took another position in
Ithaca, and in 1883 he accepted a position in
Holyoke, Massachusetts. In 1885 Stryker became pastor of the Fourth Presbyterian Church in Chicago. Styker was a popular speaker, and widely quoted in his day. As Hamilton's president, Stryker strongly defended the traditional approach to a liberal arts education, and preserved the teaching of the
classics. He was one of the signers of the
Blackstone Memorial advocating the creation of a Jewish State as a solution to anti-Jewish pogroms in Russia. Stryker also compiled and wrote poetry and hymns. With
Hubert Platt Main, he jointly edited
The Church Praise Book (1882) and contributed 9 original pieces, and the
New Alleluia (1880–86). Stryker also edited
Christian Chorals, for the Chapel and Fireside (1885), and
Church Song (1889; including 19 original contributions). He also published
Hymns and Verses (1883), and
Song of Miriam, and Other Hymns and Verses (1888) and
College Hymnal (1897, including 27 of his works published 1890–1894). His verse
Latermath was published in 1896. He also wrote
An Outline Study of the History of the Bible in English: With a Brief Essay on its Quality as Literature. After his retirement, Stryker continued as a trustee of Hamilton College as well as Auburn Theological Seminary. ==Personal life==