Fox News described them as "bright orange" with a "pretty unusual" shape. The
Chicago Tribunes Joseph Hernandez called the color of the menu item "neon-orange".
Consequence of Sounds Ben Kaye remarked that they were "new cat poop-shaped fried mac and Cheeto cheese curls".
Consumerists Ashlee Kieler perceived its color as "glowing, orange-ish".
The Verges Dami Lee commented that they were "coagulated orange clumps of processed cheese".
Bloomberg Newss Leslie Patton said it was "portable macaroni-and-cheese bites are similar to mozzarella sticks".
Food & Wines Mike Pomranz said "Like a
car crash, this bizarre mashup is just too intense to ignore."
The Raw Storys Brad Reed saw it as "radioactive-orange" and "
Trump-colored", but remarked "do look marginally more appetizing than the terrifying bright-red
Whopper Burger King released earlier this year".
Vices Alex Swerdloff noted the product as "a chode-like mass" and resembling "the lovechild of E.T.’s finger and a bloated corpse that was given a spray tan".
Yahoo! Styles Claire Lower called them "orange nuggets".
The Denver Posts Megan McArdle reported it "bearing the same resemblance to real food as a plastic Lego tree does to a stately elm".
The Guardians Joshua David Stein said the Cheetos crust was "bright orange".
The Capital Timess Rob Thomas said they were "five stubby cylinders that look like mozzarella sticks, dusted heavily with orange Cheeto dust".
Business Insider performed a
blind taste test for Mac n' Cheetos. About half of the testers were repulsed by the product.
Fox News Channel's
Chew On This enacted a blind taste test for Mac n' Cheetos in the streets of
New York City. Reception proved positive. In the web series
Juggalos Review Foods, two
Insane Clown Posse fans (or
Juggalos) tried the Mac n' Cheetos with a more mixed reception. One of the hosts appraised the food product with "this tastes like processed weird gross mac and cheese-like gimmicky piece of crap food item from Burger King".
USA Todays Ted Berg said "they’re not good" but also "not totally awful" either.
Kotakus Mike Fahey said "pleased to report that Mac n’ Cheetos taste much better than they look" but also that they do not taste like the cheese puff but rather like the
Kellogg's cracker
Cheez-It.
Chicago Tribunes Joseph Hernandez described the meal as "gritty, fried nugget of Easy Mac, rolled in the remains of the bottom of a bag of Cheetos".
Yahoo! Styles Claire Lower said "I liked them but, maybe this is because my standards for stunt food are much too high, I didn't love them."
The Capital Timess Rob Thomas reviewed the interior of the Mac n' Cheetos favorably stating "does indeed have the satisfying cheesy blandness of a container of quick-zapped microwave Easy Mac, salty and starchy". However, Thomas was critical of how it did not taste like Cheetos saying "[i]t’s very disappointing". When the menu item was brought back in October 2016 by Sheetz,
Consumerists Laura Northrup described them as "orange breaded carbohydrate globs."
Fortunes Michal Addady called it "essentially fried mac and cheese coated with flavoring from Cheetos, a PepsiCo brand."
Bustles Claire Warner described Mac n' Cheetos returning via Sheetz as "the Internet basically threw a party." When the food item returned to the Burger King menu on May 18, 2017,
Eater.coms Amanda Kludt described it as "novelty dish and
millennial-bait."
Brit + Cos Maggie McCracken ranked Mac n' Cheetos #1 on the list "10 Most Popular Mac and Cheese #Cheatday Meals on Instagram" with "a
WHOPping (get it?)" 35,000
likes on
Instagram.
Bustles Claire Warner said "it sounds like what happens when you accidentally drop a glob of macaroni and cheese into a half-consumed bag of Cheetos resting on your lap, and a few hours later, you decide to eat said glob because it's 2 a.m. and nobody's watching. You already know if this is something you're into." == Price ==