In December 1894, Prime Minister
John Sparrow David Thompson died suddenly, and Bowell, as the most senior Cabinet minister, was appointed in Thompson's stead by the Governor General. Bowell thus became the second of just two Canadian prime ministers (after
John Abbott) to hold that office while serving in the Senate rather than the House of Commons.
Manitoba Schools Question As Prime Minister, Bowell faced the
Manitoba Schools Question. In 1890,
Manitoba had abolished public funding for denominational schools, both
Catholic and
Protestant, which many thought was contrary to the provisions made for denominational schools in the
Manitoba Act of 1870. However, in a court challenge, the
Judicial Committee of the Privy Council held that Manitoba's abolition of public funding for denominational schools was consistent with the
Manitoba Act provision. In a second court case, the Judicial Committee held that the federal Parliament had the authority to enact remedial legislation to force Manitoba to re-establish the funding.
Leadership crisis Bowell and his predecessors struggled to solve this problem, which divided the country and even Bowell's own Cabinet. He was further hampered in his handling of the issue by his own indecisiveness on it and by his inability, as a senator, to take part in debates in the House of Commons. Bowell backed legislation, already drafted, that would have forced Manitoba to restore its Catholic schools, but then postponed it due to opposition within his Cabinet. With the ordinary business of government at a standstill, several members of Cabinet decided that Bowell was incompetent to lead. To force him to step down, seven ministers resigned and then foiled the appointment of successors. Bowell denounced them as "a nest of traitors".
Resignation Bowell was forced to resign as prime minister. After ten days, following an intervention on Bowell's behalf by the Governor General, the government crisis was resolved and matters seemingly returned to normal when six of the ministers were reinstated, but leadership was then effectively held by
Charles Tupper, who had joined Cabinet at the same time, filling the seventh place. Tupper, who had been Canadian
High Commissioner to the
United Kingdom, had been recalled by the plotters to replace Bowell. Bowell formally resigned in favour of Tupper at the end of the parliamentary session. ==Later life and death==