Critical response Mad Men received critical acclaim throughout its run, The
American Film Institute selected it as one of the top ten television programs in each year it aired: 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, 2012, 2013, 2014, and was singled out for the "Special Award" in 2015 to honor the show's final season and legacy. It was named the best television show of 2007 by the
Television Critics Association and several national publications, including the
Chicago Tribune,
The New York Times, the
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette,
Time, and
TV Guide. The show appeared on multiple year-end "most acclaimed" lists published by critics throughout all of its seasons. According to
Metacritic's aggregate of such lists, it was the most acclaimed show in 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, the second most acclaimed in 2012, the fourth most acclaimed in 2013, the seventh most acclaimed in 2014, and the second most acclaimed in 2015. On the review aggregator website Metacritic, the first season scored 77/100; the second season scored 88/100; the third season scored 87/100; the fourth season scored 92/100; the fifth season scored 89/100; the sixth season scored 88/100; the seventh season, part one scored 85/100; and the seventh season, part two scored 83/100. A
New York Times reviewer called the series groundbreaking for "luxuriating in the not-so-distant past." Regarding season 3, Matthew Gilbert of
The Boston Globe wrote "it's an absolutely gorgeous, amber-tinted vision of the early 1960s" and added "detailed with enough 1950s-era accoutrements to seem authentically Camelot." The
San Francisco Chronicle called
Mad Men "stylized, visually arresting...an adult drama of introspection and the inconvenience of modernity in a man's world." A
Chicago Sun-Times reviewer described the series as an "unsentimental portrayal of complicated 'whole people' who act with the more decent 1960 manners America has lost, while also playing grab-ass and crassly defaming subordinates." The reaction at
Entertainment Weekly was similar, noting how in the period in which
Mad Men takes place, "play is part of work, sexual banter isn't yet harassment, and America is free of self-doubt, guilt, and countercultural confusion." The
Los Angeles Times said that the show had found "a strange and lovely space between nostalgia and political correctness." The show also received critical praise for its historical accuracy – mainly its depictions of gender and racial bias, sexual dynamics in the workplace, and the high prevalence of smoking and drinking.
The Washington Post agreed with most other reviews in regard to
Mad Men visual style, but disliked what was referred to as "lethargic" pacing of the storylines. A review of the first season DVD set in the
London Review of Books by Mark Greif was much less laudatory. Greif stated that the series was an "unpleasant little entry in the genre of Now We Know Better" as the cast was a series of historical stereotypes that failed to do anything except "congratulate the present." In a February 2011 review of the show's first four seasons, critic
Daniel Mendelsohn wrote a critical review that called
Mad Men a "drama with aspirations to treating social and historical 'issues'—the show is
melodramatic rather than dramatic." It was ranked 21st in
TV Guides 2013 list of the 60 best TV series ever, and the Writers Guild of America named it seventh in a list of the 101 best-written shows in the history of television. In 2019,
The Guardian, which ranked the show 3rd on its list of the 100 best TV shows of the 21st century, stated that by spanning the entire 60s,
Mad Men showed "the mammoth social shifts in an ad agency in minute detail, and became...a meditation on how modern America came to be made, one iconic advert at a time." Rob Sheffield of
Rolling Stone called
Mad Men "the greatest TV drama of all time." In 2022,
Rolling Stone ranked
Mad Men as the seventh-greatest TV show of all time. In 2023,
Variety chose
Mad Men as the #2 greatest TV show of all time. In October 2023, chief critics of
The Hollywood Reporter ranked
Mad Men the greatest show of the 21st century, stating that "In strange ways,
Mad Men was more optimistic than its prestige television cohorts, and in many other ways it was more cynical. Reconciling those two seemingly contradictory impulses over seven seasons was heartbreaking, hilarious, bleak and inspiring, generating a lifetime of instantly recognizable memes, marvelously quotable dialogue and indelible moments."
Ratings Viewership for the premiere at 10:00 pm on July 19, 2007, was higher than any other AMC original series at that time, and attained a 1.4
household rating, with 1.2 million households and 1.65 million total viewers. The numbers for the first season premiere were more than doubled for the heavily promoted second season premiere, which received 2.06 million viewers. A major drop in viewership for the episode following the second season premiere prompted concern from some television critics. The third season premiere, which aired August 16, 2009, garnered 2.8 million views on its first run, and 0.78 million with the 11:00 pm and 1:00 am repeats. In 2009,
Mad Men was second in
Nielsen's list of Top 10
timeshifted primetime TV programs, with a 57.7% gain in viewers, second only to the final season of
Battlestar Galactica. The fourth season premiere received 2.9 million viewers, and was up five percent from the ratings for the debut of season 3 and up 61 percent from the third season average, and became the most watched-episode in AMC history until its fifth season premiere, and later, the series premieres of
The Walking Dead and
Better Call Saul. The fifth season premiere, "
A Little Kiss", was the most watched episode of
Mad Men of all time to date, receiving 3.54 million viewers and 1.6 million viewers in the 18–49 demographic. Before the fifth season,
Mad Men had never achieved above a 1.0 in the 18–49 demographic. Charlie Collier, AMC's president, said that: The fifth season finale, "
The Phantom", was watched by 2.7 million viewers, which was the highest ratings for a
Mad Men finale until the series finale aired on May 17, 2015. In 2012, the series was second in Nielsen's list of Top 10 timeshifted primetime TV programs, with a 127% gain in viewers. On April 7, 2013, the sixth season premiered to 3.37 million viewers, and 1.1 adults 18–49. and 1.4 million were ages 18–49, making it the highest viewed and highest rated episode since the sixth season premiere. According to Robert Levinson, a consultant for
Mad Men who worked at
BBDO from 1960 to 1980, "what [Matthew Weiner] captured was so real. The drinking was commonplace, the smoking was constant, the relationships between the executives and the secretaries was exactly right".
George Lois, who worked at
Doyle Dane Bernbach for a year, before starting
his own ad agency in 1960, said:
Mad Men is nothing more than the fulfilment of every possible stereotype of the early 1960s bundled up nicely to convince consumers that the sort of morally repugnant behavior exhibited by its characters...is glamorous and vintage.... [U]nlike the TV 'Mad Men,' we worked full, exhausting, joyous days: pitching new business, creating ideas, "comping" them up, storyboarding them, selling them, photographing them, and directing commercials. And our only 'extracurricular activity' was chasing fly balls and dunking basketballs on our agency softball and basketball teams! Andrew Cracknell, author of
The Real Mad Men: The Renegades of Madison Avenue and the Golden Age of Advertising, also thought the show lacked authenticity, stating, "One thing of which they[...] are all equally contemptuous", in regards to the industry's elite, "is the output of Sterling Cooper. But then they have every right. None of them would ever have wanted to work for Draper and none of his departments would have got a job at any of their agencies. Particularly Draper himself. Too phony." According to an analysis of the language used in
Mad Men by Benjamin Schmidt, a visiting graduate fellow at the
Cultural Observatory at
Harvard University, the vocabulary and phrases used in the show are not all quite authentic to the period, despite attempts to use contemporary vocabulary. Using a computer program, he determined that the show uses relatively few words that are clearly anachronistic but that there are many words and phrases used that are far more common in modern speech, than in the speech of the era ("need to", "feel good about", "euthanize", etc). In aggregate these words and constructions give a misleading impression of the speech patterns of the time. He notes that the use of modern business language (leverage, signing bonus, etc.) unknown or little used at the time "creeps in with striking regularity."
Legacy and influence Mad Men is widely considered one of the most influential shows in the medium's history and has had an enduring impact on modern television. It raised the profile of
AMC, and it was the first series on basic cable to win the
Primetime Emmy Award for Outstanding Drama Series, winning a record four times, tied only with
Hill Street Blues,
L.A. Law,
The West Wing and
Game of Thrones for most wins in that category.
Mad Mens success allowed AMC to greenlight other series, such as
Breaking Bad, and it also inspired several other networks to launch their own prestige drama series. As a result, many TV critics credit
Mad Men and AMC with starting a new wave of
Peak TV. Many elements of the show were commended including its unique episode and season structures, subtle and atmospheric tone, exploration of feminism, attention to detail and its overall approach regarding history.
Mad Men also inspired several other TV shows during its run. The 2009
TNT series
Trust Me, which ran for one season, was set at a modern-day advertising agency; television critic
Tom Shales called it a cross between
Mad Men and another television show,
Nip/Tuck. Two network television series that premiered in 2011, the short-lived
The Playboy Club and the one-season
Pan Am, both set in 1963, were frequently referred to as imitations of
Mad Men. The British TV drama
The Hour, which also premiered in 2011, and is set in 1956, was also described as influenced by
Mad Men. The 2014
Syfy miniseries
Ascension was described as "
Mad Men in space". Several other shows have been compared to and said to have been influenced by
Mad Men as well, including
The Americans,
Halt and Catch Fire,
The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel,
Boardwalk Empire, and
BoJack Horseman, amongst many others. Don Draper's rendition of the
Frank O'Hara poem "Mayakovsky" from
Meditations in an Emergency, at the end of "For Those Who Think Young" (season two, episode one), led to the poet's work entering the top 50 sales on
Amazon.com.
Mad Men was credited with setting off a wave of renewed interest in the fashion and culture of the early 1960s. According to
The Guardian in 2008, the show was responsible for a revival in men's suits, especially suits resembling those of that period, with higher waistbands and shorter jackets; as well as "everything from tortoise shell glasses to
fedoras." According to the website
BabyCenter, the show led to the name "Betty" soaring in popularity for baby girls in the United States in 2010. According to
The Arizona Republic, a resurgence in interest for
Mid-century modern furnishings and decor also coincided with the emergence of the show.
New York Times theater critic
Ben Brantley wrote in 2011 that the success of
Mad Men had turned "the booze-guzzling, chain-smoking, babe-chasing 1960s" into "Broadway's decade du jour", citing three 1960s-set musicals that had appeared on Broadway in the past year: revivals of
Promises, Promises and
How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying, and a new musical,
Catch Me If You Can. Brantley also wrote, "I'm presuming that
Mad Men is the reason this
Promises, Promises is set not in the late '60s, as the original was, but in 1962." The appearance of Christina Hendricks as office manager Joan, is said to have sparked a renewed interest in a voluptuous look for women and to be partly responsible for, among other things, a 10 percent increase in
breast augmentation in the United Kingdom in 2010. The nostalgia for the fashions and social norms of the early 1960s engendered by
Mad Men was criticized by some commentators. Amy Benfer, writing in 2009 for
Salon, asked, "But isn't it a little odd that a show that, among other things, warns about the dangers of seeing the past in too amber a light has spawned an industry devoted to fetishizing nostalgia for that same flawed past?" In the
2014 State of the Union Address, President
Barack Obama, in speaking out against unequal pay for women, said "It's time to do away with workplace policies that belong in a
Mad Men episode." Matthew Weiner released a statement saying that he "supports the president", and that he was "honored that our show is part of a much-needed national conversation". In 2015, a sculpture of a bench dedicated to
Mad Men featuring the image of Don Draper from the opening credit sequence was unveiled in front of the
Time-Life Building.
Awards and accolades Mad Men was the recipient of many nominations and awards from various organizations, including the American Film Institute,
Emmys and
Creative Arts Emmys from the
Academy of Television Arts & Sciences, a
Peabody Award from the Peabody Board at the
Grady College of Journalism and Mass Communication,
Satellite Awards from the
International Press Academy, and
British Academy Television Awards from the
British Academy of Film and Television Arts. Numerous nominations and award were also received from guilds and societies such as the
Art Directors Guild,
Casting Society of America,
Cinema Audio Society,
Costume Designers Guild,
Directors Guild of America,
Motion Picture Sound Editors,
Producers Guild of America,
Screen Actors Guild, Television Critics Association and Writers Guild of America. Award highlights include winning the Primetime Emmy Award for Outstanding Drama Series four times, for each of its first four seasons; its fourth win tied the record for
serial dramas set earlier by
Hill Street Blues (1981–84),
L.A. Law (1987, 1989–91), and
The West Wing (2000–03). In 2012,
Mad Men set a record for the most Emmy nominations, 17, without winning. A 2015
The Hollywood Reporter survey of 2,800 actors, producers, directors, and other industry people named it as their #9 favorite show. ==Marketing==