Made in the Dark charted for 23 weeks in over 10 different charts, entering the
UK Album Chart at number four, The album, according to
Nielsen SoundScan data reported by
Billboard, has sold 47,000 copies and has been certified Gold for UK sales. "Shake a Fist", the first single to be released from the album, was released on 12"
vinyl single at the beginning of October 2007 but did not chart. The second single released, "Ready for the Floor", charted for 24 weeks in five different charts, peaking at number six on the UK Singles Top 75.
Critical reception Made in the Dark received generally positive reviews from music critics. At
Metacritic, which assigns a
normalised rating out of 100 to reviews from mainstream publications, the album received an
average score of 78, based on 40 reviews. with similar comments from
AllMusic who said, "
Made in the Dark main weakness might be its ballads, but that may just be in comparison to its many energetic moments, which are so addictive that it feels like a forced come-down whenever the band slows things down." However,
The Observer gave a positive evaluation of the ballads; "Hot Chip have had a happy way with a subliminal power ballad. And
Made in the Dark can boast four of the best."
Pitchfork described it as a "patchy, turbulent record" due to the use of many different individual components and also said that it was a "good record but not a great one". Martin responded to the criticism made by
Pitchfork:
Pitchfork, despite their initial rating, went on to list the album number 23 on their list of the fifty best albums of 2008, and would later state that "its bold charms have lent it a fond longevity." Another element that caused mixed reception was the use of a Todd Rundgren sample in "Shake a Fist", which
musicOMH called "delightful" but
The Guardian described it as grating.
musicOMH, whose description of the album was positive, said that tracks "Ready for the Floor" and "Bendable Poseable" had elements reminiscent of previous album
The Warning. In regards to lyrics,
AllMusic said the album "boasts some of Hot Chip's most
kinetic music, with rhythms and melodies that are just as hyper-articulate as the
word play." == Track listing ==