As Sweat and Riley began to work together, the music to "I Want Her" and "Make It Last Forever" had been made prior to them meeting each other. Riley described the recording process as organic, as he had no plans to do R&B music. As the two worked on the melodies and arrangements, Riley contributed the primary background vocals to "I Want Her". Riley also asked Sweat to sing in a nasal tone to have a distinctive sound for him. Sweat objected to that decision and walked out of the room before recording the song. Although Sweat refused to record the song with the nasal voice, Riley convinced him that it would work for him, which made Sweat come around to recording the song. "Something Just Ain't Right" was worked on at Riley's house and was inspired by something going on in Sweat's life with his then-girlfriend. According to Riley, the songs "Make It Last Forever" and "How Deep Is Your Love" were recorded with Sweat singing the lyrics off the top of his head. Musicians such as
Fred McFarlane and
GQ member Emmanuel Rahiem LeBlanc also contributed in various forms. However, on "Right and a Wrong Way", Riley had to perform a saxophone solo on the keyboard because he wasn't able to find someone who could play the saxophone. Riley described Sweat as an "over-perfectionist" who would record the songs "again and again until he gets it the way he likes it". It took six months to record
Make It Last Forever, to which they recorded 16 or 17 songs, but only eight of them made the final track listing. One of the songs that didn't make the album was "
Just Got Paid". Sweat passed on it, which Riley later gave to
Johnny Kemp for his 1988 album
Secrets of Flying. == Critical reception ==