On November 26, 1980, Robbins was arrested in
Millville, New Jersey, for the murder of 9-year-old Evan Bailey, who had been abducted, raped and murdered in
Vineland just nine days prior. He indicated the dumping site to local authorities, and a coroner concluded that Bailey had been raped, beaten and stabbed multiple times in the neck. Robbins immediately admitted to the crime, and to the shock of the investigators, he claimed to have committed similar murders in other states. According to his confessions, his first victim was 7-year-old Stephen Craig Little, who was killed on December 27, 1979, in
Dallas,
Texas. Robbins had just left California and arrived in Dallas, whereupon he lured Little - who was playing on a playground - into his van. He then raped and strangled him, dumping the body in a garbage can and setting it on fire. The victim's charred remains were found on the following morning. His testimony was considered truthful as he had shared details known only to investigators at the time. Despite this, he later recanted and claimed he had still been in Palm Springs at the time. However, he was unable to provide an alibi for the date of Little's murder, and several witnesses placed him in Dallas at the time of the crime. The next victim was 17-year-old William Byran Lepko, who was reported missing on January 29, 1980, from
Wheeling, West Virginia. Robbins himself claimed that after he had convinced Finney to get on his motorcycle, he took the boy to a wooded area and raped him. Immediately afterwards, Finney began to kick the tires of his bike, angering Robbins and prompting him to strangle the boy to death. He claimed that he had stolen some of Finney's clothes and brought them to his apartment. A few days later, he sold the motorcycle, moved out of his apartment, and left town. In the aftermath of these confessions, police searched the apartment where Robbins and his partner lived at the time and found Finney's T-shirt, which had been given as a gift to Robbins' lover.
Unconfirmed and disproven victims In addition to these murders, Robbins either claimed to have committed or was considered a suspect in similar killings in other states. In the fall of 1980, he said that he had killed an unidentified young boy in
Minden, Nevada. The boy's body was found on November 10 and was later identified as missing Sunnyvale, CA teen, John Edward Powers, aged 15 (Douglas County Sheriff's Office, NV). Robbins was also a suspect in the murders of 5-year-old Teresa Lynn Flores and 4-year-old Martha Joanne Mezo, whose bodies were found a in shallow grave near the
Salinas River near
San Miguel, California, on May 29, 1980. Investigators noted similarities between their killings and that of Finney, but after numerous interrogations, Robbins was ruled out as a suspect. He was also briefly considered a suspect in the
Atlanta Child Murders, as he had lived in the city at the time, but was eventually ruled out as a suspect. == Trials, sentence, and imprisonment ==