While on a tour of the
Andamans as the Cabinet Minister in the later part of 2004, Aiyar was quoted as saying at the
Cellular Jail there that there was no difference between Hindutva ideologue
Vinayak Savarkar and Pakistan's founder
Mohammed Ali Jinnah as they shared a 'divisive' philosophy. He also ordered that a plaque with a poem commemorating Savarkar be replaced with a plaque with quotes from
Mahatma Gandhi. Reports of the incident paralysed
Parliament and led to agitations by the
Shiv Sena in
Maharashtra. Aiyar's remarks created confusion as well in the ruling party; the official spokesman,
Anand Sharma, noted that the
Congress Party did not consider Savarkar either a freedom fighter or a patriot. A few days later, the Prime Minister dissociated himself and the cabinet from that view.
A. P. J. Abdul Kalam administering the oath as Cabinet Minister at a Swearing-in Ceremony in New Delhi on 2004. In September 2011, Aiyar visited his alma mater—
St. Stephen's College—to speak about 'Governance and Corruption: Is Panchayati Raj A Solution?'. However, he began to mock the
Hansraj College and its former student
Ajay Maken. He also belittled the
Kirori Mal College and the BA (Programme) Degree, a course in the University of Delhi. This led to an agitation by the students of Hansraj College. When the agitated students approached him, he mocked them even further. When later questioned by the media, Aiyar refused to apologise and rather ridiculed the institutions even further. Baffled by his remarks, Stephen's College and its students went on to apologise to Hansraj College and extended a hand of friendship. Pranab Mukherjee releasing a book authored by
12th Vice-President of India Mohammad Hamid Ansari, in New Delhi on 2008. He in an interview days before the run up to the 2014 Parliament elections in India, said that a tea seller (The Prime Ministerial candidate
Narendra Modi of the
BJP) can never become the Prime Minister of India, but can sell tea in
AICC meetings. His comment was disowned by the Congress saying it's his personal view and not the party's view.
Rahul Gandhi asked him not to make personal attacks. Mani Shankar Aiyer justified the
November 2015 Paris attacks as a response to France banning hijab. He also justified the
Charlie Hebdo shooting as a backlash for the death of Muslims. His comments were disapproved by his own party members. He sparked a political firestorm when he called Prime Minister Narendra Modi a "
neech aadmi". Subsequently, he was temporarily suspended from the party's primary membership. Aiyar said the comments by the PM showed his "low-level mindset and one bereft of any manners". He further justified his remarks on Modi by adding "Yes, I called Modi 'neech' but did not mean it as a low-born; I meant it as low". ==Publications==