Critical response On
Rotten Tomatoes the film has an approval rating of 15% based on 136 reviews, with an average rating of 3.90/10. The site's critics consensus reads: "While it boasts some stylish action,
Max Payne suffers severely from an illogical plot and overdirection."
Metacritic gave the film a weighted average score of 31 out of 100 based on 25 critics, indicating "generally unfavorable reviews". Audiences surveyed by
CinemaScore gave the film an average grade of "C" on an A+ to F scale. Louise Keller said "The most striking element is the production design..." Bruce Paterson wrote for the
Australian Film Critics Association that "Mark Wahlberg is terrific in hard-bitten roles", but in a reference to the Valkyries concluded, "it could have done with more of the Norse and less of the force." Critic
Armond White has defended the film stating that Moore "explores genuine, contemporary anxiety [and that] his images are richer than his plots." On
IGN, Jim Vejvoda said: "It also doesn't help that Wahlberg gives a drab performance..." and "the rest of the cast doesn't fare much better." He stated that gamers will be disappointed when comparing it to the game and even as a revenge film there is not much here. IGN went on to give Max Payne the "Best Videogame Adaptation" award of 2008, noting "this is how sad games-to-film have become that the only one worthy of being named the "best" of the year is a movie that we panned." One of the harshest critics of the film,
3D Realms CEO Scott Miller, one of the game's producers, cited fundamental story flaws "that have me shaking my head in bewilderment," including the game's opening scenes being instead placed in the middle of the film. After the film's No. 1 opening weekend, however, he retracted his comments, saying that he was now "proud of the film," and that "this kind of opening brings us a lot closer to the reality of a sequel" to the long-stalled video game series.
Awards Mark Wahlberg received a
Golden Raspberry Award nomination for
Worst Actor for his performance in the film (also for
The Happening), but "lost" to
Mike Myers for
The Love Guru.
Box office Max Payne opened at No. 1 at the box office, with $17,639,849 during its first weekend against newcomers
Sex Drive,
The Secret Life of Bees, and
W. The film earned $40,689,393 domestically, and $44,727,512 overseas, making a worldwide total of $85,416,905. While it is not considered an overwhelming success, its U.S. gross was around the same range as other video game adaptations such as
Hitman,
Silent Hill, and
Resident Evil. Its international gross was lower than both
Silent Hill and
Hitman, and it was significantly lower than that of the six live-action
Resident Evil films released to date. The film ranks nineteenth in U.S. box-office gross revenues for video game adaptions.
Home media The film was released on
DVD and
Blu-ray on January 20, 2009, and as of August 2009 generated $25,915,457 in DVD sales. It went on to receive a score of 7 out of 10 on
IGN, being described as "a first-rate transfer that manages to show off the range of the high-definition format with few, if any, real weaknesses". ==Differences from the game==