Disputed by Mountbatten-Windsor and Maxwell In
his 2019 BBC interview with
Emily Maitlis, Andrew said that he had "absolutely no memory of that photograph ever being taken" but that he recognised himself in the photograph. He also said that "from the investigations that we've done, you can't prove whether or not that photograph is faked or not because it is a photograph of a photograph of a photograph. So it's very difficult to be able to prove it but I don't remember that photograph ever being taken" and that he did not "believe that photograph was taken in the way that has been suggested". She stated that there was "no original of that photo, [only] copies of it that have been produced, copies of copies. Parts of it, according to some experts, look like they have been photoshopped". In a 2023 article for
News.com.au, Daniela Elser wrote that the windows of Maxwell's house on Kinnerton Street look "near-identical" to the windows in the photograph. A "draft statement" sent by a "G Maxwell" in 2015 to Epstein stated "In 2001 I was in London when [redacted] met a number of friends of mine including Prince Andrew. A photograph was taken as I imagine she wanted to show it to friends and family". Giuffre's brother said that the email "... truly does vindicate Virginia... she was not lying this entire time". In 2025,
an email written by Epstein in 2011 was released by the House Oversight Committee in which he stated that "Yes she [Giuffre] was on my plane and yes she had her picture taken with Andrew". ==Existence and location of the original photograph==