In its original broadcast, "Mayored to the Mob" finished 24th in ratings for the week of December 14–20, 1998, with a
Nielsen rating of 8.6, equivalent to approximately 8.5 million viewing households. It was the second highest-rated show on the Fox network that week, following
Ally McBeal.
Empire named Hamill's performance in the episode as the tenth-best film gag in the show, commenting: "As a rule, celebrity cameos are rubbish, but good sport Hamill is hilarious when singing 'Luke, be a Jedi tonight' in a production of
Guys and Dolls, and makes this list for urging bodyguard Homer to 'use the forks. Eric Goldman, Dan Iverson and Brian Zoromski of
IGN marked Hamill's guest appearance second on a list of "Top 25
Simpsons Guest appearances" saying that much of the episode's humor came from Hamill being "a good sport about his past". In addition, Hamill ranked 18th on
AOL's list of their favorite 25
Simpsons guest stars, and
Total Film's Nathan Ditum ranked his performance as the third-best guest appearance in the show's history. Simon Crerar of
The Times also listed Hamill's performance as one of the thirty-three funniest cameos in the history of
The Simpsons. The authors of the book ''I Can't Believe It's a Bigger and Better Updated Unofficial Simpsons Guide'', Warren Martyn and Adrian Wood, wrote that "the best bits all involve either the convention or Mark Hamill's repeated attempts to not be mobbed. Sadly, the main thrust of the story – Homer's protection of Quimby from Don Tony – falls a bit flat. Nevertheless, when the jokes run free, they are of exceptionally high quality." IGN named it as the best episode of season 10.
Screen Rant called it the best episode of the 10th season. ==References==