In a contemporary review, Arthur D. Murphy of
Variety called the film "a good contemporary crime actioner" that was "extremely well cast. Coproducer Lawrence Roman's script has some good twists, turns and ironies, caught well by director
John Sturges."
Kevin Thomas of the
Los Angeles Times compared
McQ favorably to the recent
Magnum Force (the sequel to
Dirty Harry): "The most intriguing aspect of John Wayne's diverting but undistinguished new picture
McQ at selected theaters is its similarity to Clint Eastwood's
Magnum Force ... The difference—and it may be crucial—is that Wayne, blustering and bombastic as ever, dominates his film whereas it's violence for violence's sake that takes over
Magnum Force. Eastwood's film looks lots more chic, but
McQ has lots more humanity."
Gene Siskel of the
Chicago Tribune gave the film two-and-a-half stars out of four and wrote: "Like so many of his recent movies,
McQ would be nothing without Wayne. In fact, less than nothing, because tho its story takes a high number of unexpected turns, the pacing is excruciatingly slow, its supporting characters excruciatingly vapid. And yet the film holds together around Wayne."
Pauline Kael also criticized the pace, dismissing the film as "prostratingly dull", as did
Nora Sayre of
The New York Times, who wrote: "In this wildly undramatic picture, music and gunshots have to provide the gumption that the acting lacks. Surely Mr. Wayne should stick to Westerns: he's simply too slow to play any kind of policeman. Horseless in the streets of Seattle, he looks as though he needs a shot of sand." Gary Arnold of
The Washington Post wrote: "
McQ can be recommended if you're in the mood for a commercial movie so stiff and perfunctory that it becomes unintentionally funny ... Wayne really should have enough savvy to realize that he looks ridiculous speeding around town in a green Hornet. This sporty image doesn't do anything for him anymore than his toupee does." Retrospectively, James M. Tate of
Cult Film Freaks said the movie has a
film noir quality: "Director John Sturges was, like Wayne, best known for making Westerns, a genre
McQ borrows from with the maverick loner versus an eclectic string of feisty (and often sneaky) antagonists, each with their own lethal agenda, sometimes even coming out of the woodwork with guns blazing. But with the cool looking MAC-10 submachine gun and a snaky trail pitting one man against shadowy odds, this is really a modern Noir thriller providing a chance to see the American icon grittier, and often more vulnerable, than ever before: at least in a modern setting." On
review aggregator website
Rotten Tomatoes, the film has an approval rating of 45% based on 11 reviews. ==See also==