Upon its 1944 release,
Meet Me in St. Louis was a gigantic critical and commercial success. During its initial theatrical release, it earned a then-massive $5,016,000 in the US and Canada and $1,550,000 elsewhere, resulting in a profit of $2,359,000.
Time called
Meet Me in St. Louis "one of the year's prettiest pictures" and wrote: "
Technicolor has seldom been more affectionately used than in its registrations of the sober mahoganies and tender muslins and benign gaslights of the period. Now & then, too, the film gets well beyond the charm of mere tableau for short flights in the empyrean of genuine domestic poetry. These triumphs are creditable mainly to the intensity and grace of Margaret O'Brien and to the ability of director Minnelli & Co. to get the best out of her." O'Brien drew further praise from
Time: "[Her] song and her
cakewalk done in a nightgown at a grown-up party, are entrancing acts. Her self-terrified Halloween adventures richly set against firelight, dark streets, and the rusty confabulations of fallen leaves, bring this section of the film very near the first-rate." In
The New Yorker,
Wolcott Gibbs called the film "extremely attractive" and the dialogue "funny in a sense rather rare in the movies", though he felt the film was too long. In 2005,
Richard Schickel included the film in Time.com's list of the 100 best films, writing: "It had wonderful songs [and] a sweetly unneurotic performance by Judy Garland....Despite its nostalgic charm, Minnelli infused the piece with a dreamy, occasionally surreal, darkness and it remains, for some of us, the greatest of American movie musicals." Film historian
Karina Longworth also noted its fantastical and surreal elements, calling it "a
gothic art film in disguise as a standard Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer musical". Producer Arthur Freed remarked: "
Meet Me in St. Louis is my personal favorite. I got along wonderfully with Judy, but the only time we were ever on the outs was when we did this film. She didn't want to do the picture. Even her mother came to me about it. We bumped into some trouble with some opinions—
Eddie Mannix, the studio manager, thought the Halloween sequence was wrong, but it was left in. There was a song that
Rodgers and Hammerstein had written, called
Boys and Girls Like You and Me, that Judy did wonderfully, but it slowed up the picture and it was cut out. After the preview of the completed film, Judy came over to me and said, 'Arthur, remind me not to tell you what kind of pictures to make.' [It] was the biggest grosser Metro had up to that time, except for
Gone With the Wind."
Meet Me in St. Louis holds a 99% "Fresh" rating on the
review aggregation website Rotten Tomatoes based on 81 reviews with an average score of 8.70/10. The site's critics' consensus for the film reads: "A disarmingly sweet musical led by outstanding performances from Judy Garland and Margaret O'Brien,
Meet Me in St. Louis offers a holiday treat for all ages." ==Accolades==