In
Computer Gaming World,
Scorpia wrote: "Overall,
Menzoberranzan is a disappointment. It has some nice features, but nice features must be supported by a strong story. Sadly, what could have been a superior entry in the CRPG field comes off as just another hack-n-slash product". Andrew Wright of
PC Zone considered it "a case of dumb dungeoneering stylishly put together", and said that it "tries to be
Ultima Underworld and fails miserably". He offered praise to its graphics and interface. T. Liam McDonald of
PC Gamer US called
Menzoberranzan the best
Advanced Dungeons & Dragons game ever released, and praised its graphics and story, but complained that it is "combat oriented in early levels and takes its sweet time getting to the narrative elements". Ian Cole from the Quandaryland website awarded the game 3.5 stars out 5. He was critical of the slowness of the game compared to
Ravenloft and that "too many places were empty — just nothing". He praises that this was not a typical hack and slash game with a focus on game statistics for the characters as well as puzzle solving. John Terra of
Computer Shopper said the game "stands out" and called it a "must-have". According to Allen Rausch of
GameSpy, "without a great plot and exciting monsters that truly utilized its spectacular setting,
Menzoberranzan ended up being less impressive than it was in players' imaginations".
Dungeons and Desktops: The History of Computer Role-Playing Games said "the last TSR-licensed game SSI published is the infamously wretched (and hard to spell)
Menzoberranzan, which appeared in 1994 for DOS. [...] [It] had all the ingredients necessary for a hit. [...] Nevertheless, gamers quickly complained about the endless number of boring battles that drag out the game and ruin its pacing". ==References==