Just as Gattinara is noted for his
universalist idealism, he is also recognized as adept in the practice of
realpolitik. Taking over from Charles V's advisor
Carlos de Chièvres, Gattinara shifted the policy outlook of his king. Chièvres had advocated protecting the
Netherlands through understandings with France and England, attempting to avoid war with France especially. Gattinara aimed at broadening Charles from a narrow Burgundian/Spanish outlook toward a wide imperial vision. At the centre of his imperial policy was Italy:
Milan was the vital link between the
Habsburg holdings of Spain/
Franche-Comté and
Tyrol. By the last months of 1521, Gattinara had succeeded in shifting the war with France from
Navarre to Italy. His imperial strategy had two conditions for success: domination of Italy, and
alliance with Rome. Gattinara was the source of Charles's shift in policy toward Italy—no other cabinet member pushed for these policies. A year previous to Gattinara's appointment, the English ambassador Tunstal had remarked on Gattinara's preoccupation with Italy. Gattinara had drawn up advance drafts of war plans against Italy, in which he stresses that since God called Charles to be the first prince of Christendom it was fitting that he turned his attention to Italy, saying that anyone who counselled Charles against pursuing Italy in lieu of interest elsewhere was prescribing the king's ruin, shame and blame. Gattinara emphasized the low cost of an Italian campaign, and the necessary troop
mobilization necessary for overwhelming force. In deciding whether or not to advise Charles V to go to war against France in northern Italy, Gattinara constructed an allegory posing the
seven deadly sins against the
Ten Commandments—seven causes for avoiding war, and ten arguments in favour. Against, the reasons were all quite practical: an attack would place a great stake on a single
strategy with an uncertain method of solution; there was not enough money in the
treasury; negotiations with other Italian states were uncertain; the
Swiss might ally themselves with France, and the area would soon be fraught with danger from the impending winter. However, Gattinara argued that the war was justified by Charles V's bond to honour the
Pope, whom he needed as an ally. Clearly, God was on Charles's side, and to let France escape a fight would be to tempt
fate—he would not have the chance, as resources would not be mobilized so easily next time. Additionally, with the army mobilized, it would not look good to call it off at the eleventh hour. Gattinara saw to it that his ten commandments won out over the seven deadly sins. Gattinara was not an idealist when it came to policy. The
Treaty of Madrid was forced upon Francis I of France by Charles after Francis was captured. The treaty spoke in
romantic hyperbole and ended with an
oath for both rulers to undertake a
crusade together. While François signed the treaty under duress, Gattinara refused to affix the imperial seal to the document, because of his sense of
realpolitik. François would subsequently break the terms of the treaty, which had been to renounce claims in Italy, surrender Burgundy, and abandon
suzerainty over
Flanders and
Artois. == See also ==