Critical response Amy Amatangelo of the
Boston Herald gave the program a grade of "D+", commenting: "'HawthoRNe' can't make a diagnosis. It's a comedy; it's a drama. It's a mess, fronted by Jada Pinkett Smith, making a return to series television as Christina Hawthorne, the chief nursing officer for Richmond Trinity Hospital and about the closest thing to a heavenly figure on the small screen since
Roma Downey took flight on
Touched by an Angel." In a review for
Zap2it, Amatangelo commented "With each passing episode, they seem to be writing Christina (Jada Pinkett Smith) deeper and deeper into a corner. She can’t always be in an uproar about everything or always play the hero. The show cannot center around her at the expense of everyone else." Greg Braxton of the
Los Angeles Times noted, "
Tom Shales in
The Washington Post suggested 'HawthoRNe' is 'a show in need of emergency care.'" In an assessment of the program for
Bangor Daily News, Dale McGarrigle wrote that "It also pales in comparison to other original dramas on its own channel." Alan Pergament of
The Buffalo News was critical of the lead actress's decision to star in the series: "Jada Pinkett Smith, the actress married to film superstar Will Smith, must be getting a little bored lately. And now she is going to bore some of us. There is no other explanation for her decision to star in TNT's routine 'HawthoRNe' as the latest strong, flawed woman on the cable network." Robert Bianco of
USA Today wrote: "
HawthoRNe would be terrible if it were the only series on TV and the only medical drama you'd ever seen. It's just too bad it's not TV's first medical show. At least it could get credit for inventing clichés instead of rehashing them." Of the lead actress's performance in the show, Bianco commented: "Pinkett Smith's Hawthorne is tired in every sense of the word, and she's not the only one. Every character and event falls under the category of painfully predictable."
Ratings The first episode of
Hawthorne received 3.8 million viewers, with a debut at the 17th spot in the list of the "Top 20 cable network television shows for the week ending June 21, 2009". It placed directly below the
Nickelodeon episode of
iCarly, "
iDate A Bad Boy", and above the
USA Network program,
In Plain Sight. Overall, the show's first season was beaten in the ratings among adults aged 25–54 by the new
science fiction program
Warehouse 13 produced by
Syfy, and the
medical drama Royal Pains produced by
USA Network.
Awards and nominations ====
NAACP Image Awards==== •
2010: Won—Outstanding Actress in a Drama Series for Jada Pinkett Smith • 2010: Nominated—
Outstanding Drama Series • 2011: Nominated—
Outstanding Actress in a Drama Series for
Jada Pinkett Smith • 2011: Nominated—
Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Drama Series for
Vanessa Bell Calloway • 2011: Nominated—
Outstanding Drama Series • 2011: Won—OP Award ====
Prism Awards==== • 2010: Nominated—Performance in a Drama Episode for
Jada Pinkett Smith • 2010: Nominated—Drama Series Episode—Substance Use
NAMIC Vision Awards • 2010: Nominated—Drama ==References==