St. Louis Cardinals Hiring On January 24, 2008, Matheny returned to the St. Louis Cardinals as a special adviser for the first two weeks of
spring training. They announced him as their new manager on November 14, 2011, following
Tony La Russa's retirement, making him the youngest manager in the major leagues. Matheny's other prior coaching experience included
Little League Baseball, and other interviewees included
Terry Francona,
Ryne Sandberg,
José Oquendo,
Chris Maloney and
Joe McEwing, all of whom already had managerial or coaching experience in the major leagues.
First season as manager (2012) On April 4,
2012, Matheny won in his managerial debut against the
Miami Marlins in the inaugural game at
Marlins Park. Twenty days later, Matheny was ejected from a game for the first time for arguing a pivotal safe/out call by umpire
Bill Welke in the bottom of the 10th inning of a 3–2 loss to the
Chicago Cubs. Matheny's first season as Cardinals manager was a success, finishing the regular season with an 88–74 record before winning the
Wild Card game. The
Giants defeated the Cardinals in the
NLCS.
2013–14 On February 14, 2013, the Cardinals picked up Matheny's 2014 option. He surpassed the success of his first season by guiding the club in
2013 to an NL-best 97–65 record and his first
National League Central division title. The Cardinals defeated the
Pittsburgh Pirates 3–2 in the
NLDS and the
Los Angeles Dodgers 4–2 in the
NLCS for his first NL pennant. The
Boston Red Sox defeated the Cardinals in the
World Series in six games, with many similarities to 2004, when Matheny was also a catcher for St. Louis. As in the Cardinals finished with the best record in the NL, and the Red Sox likewise defeated the Cardinals in the World Series. However, in 2013, St. Louis lost four key players to season-ending injuries, including
Chris Carpenter,
Rafael Furcal,
Jaime García, and
Jason Motte, and rookies comprised half of the World Series pitching staff. On November 20, 2013, the Cardinals extended Matheny's contract for three more years through 2017. Making his first
All-Star appearance as a major leaguer, Matheny was the NL manager in the
2014 game, which he lost. The Cardinals won the NL Central division title in
2014, their second consecutive title, and third consecutive playoff appearance with Matheny as manager. More trends continued as they eliminated the
Dodgers from the playoffs for the second consecutive season, this time in the
NLDS. Just like in 2012, the
Giants eliminated the Cardinals in the
NLCS before winning the
World Series.
2015 After defeating the
Chicago Cubs 10–9 on May 4,
2015, the Cardinals had an MLB-best 19–6 record and the best 25-game start for the club since at least 1900. The seven game win streak was a career-high for Matheny. The Cardinals defeated the Cubs again the next game, 7–4, extending the win streak to eight. A 3–1 victory over the
Detroit Tigers on May 17, 2015, secured the 300th win of his managerial career. In August 2015,
Baseball America published that fellow NL managers and coaches rated Matheny the second-best manager in the league. On September 19, the Cardinals became the first team in the majors to qualify for the playoffs. Matheny became the first manager in MLB history to guide his club to the postseason in each of his first four full seasons. With an 11–1 win over the
Pittsburgh Pirates on September 30, the Cardinals won 100 games for the first time in Matheny's managerial career, while clinching their third consecutive NL Central division title. The Pirates, who had kept close for most of the season, had already won 96 games, while clinching a wild card berth. However, the Cubs, the second wild card team, defeated the Cardinals in the
NLDS in four games. Matheny finished second in the NL
Manager of the Year Award voting, and was a co-winner of the
J. G. Taylor Spink St. Louis Baseball Man of the Year Award.
2016−2018 On May 27,
2016, Matheny gained his 400th career win in a 6–2 defeat of the
Washington Nationals. In 2016, Matheny's contract was extended to 2022. On May 1, 2018, Matheny became the fourth person, following
Red Schoendienst,
Whitey Herzog, and Tony La Russa, to manage 1,000 Cardinals games. However, the Cardinals fired him on July 14, following middling performance and clubhouse issues, including Matheny's poor communication with
Dexter Fowler. His
2018 record was 47–46, and his career in St. Louis over 1,065 games was 591–474 (.555). The Cardinals did not make the postseason in his final three seasons as manager. Matheny had previously been a special advisor for player development for the Royals. The Royals exercised a contract option on March 31, 2022, retaining Matheny through the 2023 season. On October 5, 2022, the Royals fired Matheny following the dismissal of general manager
Dayton Moore. He did not have a winning season with the Royals, peaking at 74 wins in 2021.
Managerial record ==Awards and accomplishments==