H. P. Lovecraft was an admirer of James's work, extolling the stories as the peak of the ghost story form in his essay "
Supernatural Horror in Literature" (1927). Another renowned fan of James in the horror and fantasy genre was
Clark Ashton Smith, who wrote an essay on him.
Michael Sadleir described James as "the best ghost-story writer England has ever produced".
Marjorie Bowen also admired his work, referring to his ghost stories as "the supreme art of M. R. James".
Mary Butts, another admirer, wrote the first critical essay on his work, "The Art of Montagu James", in the February 1934 issue of the
London Mercury.
Manly Wade Wellman esteemed his fiction. In
The Great Railway Bazaar,
Paul Theroux refers to "
The Mezzotint" as "the most frightening story I know". In his list "The 13 Most Terrifying Horror Stories",
T. E. D. Klein placed James's "
Casting the Runes" at number one.
E. F. Bleiler stated that James is "in the opinion of many, the foremost modern writer of supernatural fiction", and he described
Ghost Stories of an Antiquary as "one of the landmark books in the history of supernatural fiction" and characterised the stories in James's other collections as "first-rate stories" and "excellent stories".
Ruth Rendell has also expressed admiration for James's work, stating, "There are some authors one wished one had never read in order to have the joy of reading them for the first time. For me, M. R. James is one of these." Sir
John Betjeman, in an introduction to Peter Haining's book about James, shows how influenced he was by James's work: In the year 1920 I was a new boy at the
Dragon School,
Oxford, then called Lynam's, of which the headmaster was C. C. Lynam, known as 'the Skipper'. He dressed and looked like an old Sea Salt, and in his gruff voice would tell us stories by firelight in the boys' room of an evening with all the lights out and his back to the fire. I remember he told the stories as having happened to himself. ... they were the best stories I ever heard, and gave me an interest in old churches, and country houses, and Scandinavia that not even the mighty
Hans Christian Andersen eclipsed. Betjeman later discovered the stories were all based on those of M. R. James.
H. Russell Wakefield's supernatural fiction was strongly influenced by the work of James. A large number of British writers deliberately wrote ghost stories in the Jamesian style; these writers, sometimes described as the "James Gang", and
R. H. Malden, although some commentators consider their stories to be inferior to those of James himself. Although most of the early Jamesian writers were male, there were several notable female writers of such fiction, including Eleanor Scott (pseudonym of Helen M. Leys, 1892–1965) in the stories of her book ''Randall's Round
(1929) and D. K. Broster in the collection Couching at the Door: Strange and Macabre Tales'' (1942). James's stories continue to influence many of today's great supernatural writers, including
Stephen King (who discusses James in the 1981 non-fiction book
Danse Macabre) and
Ramsey Campbell, who edited
Meddling with Ghosts: Stories in the Tradition of M. R. James and wrote the short story "The Guide" in tribute. The author
John Bellairs paid homage to James by incorporating plot elements borrowed from James's ghost stories into several of his own juvenile mysteries. Several of
Jonathan Aycliffe's novels, including
Whispers in the Dark and
The Matrix are influenced by James's work.
W. F. Harvey's ghost story "The Ankardyne Pew" (1928) is also a homage to James's work, which Harvey admired. The composer
Kaikhosru Shapurji Sorabji wrote two pieces for piano with a link to James:
Quaere reliqua hujus materiei inter secretiora (1940), inspired by "
Count Magnus", and
St. Bertrand de Comminges: "He was laughing in the tower" (1941), inspired by "Canon Alberic's Scrap-Book".
Gerald Heard's novel
The Black Fox, published in 1950, is an occult thriller inspired by "The Stalls of Barchester Cathedral". All the stories later appeared in Hodgson's collection
The Fellow Travellers and Other Ghost Stories (
Ash-Tree Press, 1998). On Christmas Day 1987,
The Teeth of Abbot Thomas, a James parody by Stephen Sheridan, was broadcast on Radio 4. It starred
Alfred Marks (as Abbot Thomas),
Robert Bathurst,
Denise Coffey,
Jonathan Adams and
Bill Wallis. In 1989,
Ramsey Campbell published the short story "The Guide", which takes an antiquarian on a macabre journey to a ruined church after following marginalia in a copy of James's guidebook
Suffolk and Norfolk. In 2001, Campbell edited the anthology
Meddling with Ghosts: Stories in the Tradition of M. R. James. The novelist
James Hynes wrote an updated version of "Casting the Runes" in his 1997 story collection
Publish and Perish. In 2003, Radio 4 broadcast ''The House at World's End'' by Stephen Sheridan. A pastiche of James's work, it contained numerous echoes of his stories while offering a fictional account of how he became interested in the supernatural. The older James was played by
John Rowe, and the younger James by Jonathan Keeble. Chris Priestley's ''Uncle Montague's Tales of Terror'' (2007) is a volume of ghost stories influenced by James in mood, atmosphere, and subject matter, as the title suggests. In 2008 the English experimental
neofolk duo The Triple Tree, featuring
Tony Wakeford and Andrew King from
Sol Invictus, released the album
Ghosts on which all but three songs were based upon the stories of James. One of the songs, "Three Crowns" (based on the short story "A Warning to the Curious"), also appeared on the compilation album
John Barleycorn Reborn (2007).
Helen Grant's novel
The Glass Demon (2010) was inspired by "The Treasure of Abbot Thomas". In February 2012, the UK
psychedelic band
The Future Kings of England released their fourth album,
Who Is This Who Is Coming, based on James's
'Oh, Whistle, and I'll Come to You, My Lad'. An instrumental work, it evokes the story from beginning to end, with the tracks segueing into one another to form a continuous piece of music. On 23 February 2012 the
Royal Mail released a stamp featuring James as part its "Britons of Distinction" series. In 2013, the
Fan Museum in London hosted two performances of
The Laws of Shadows, a play by Adrian Drew about M. R. James. The play is set in James's rooms at Cambridge University and deals with his relationships with his colleague
E. F. Benson and the young artist James McBryde. On 9 January 2019, in the third episode of the seventh series of the
BBC One programme
Father Brown, titled "The Whistle in the Dark", the character Professor Robert Wiseman reads a collection of ghost stories by M. R. James and later suggests that the whistle in his possession is the one described in James's Oh, Whistle, and I'll Come to You, My Lad. Comedian and writer
John Finnemore is a fan of the ghost stories of M. R. James. His radio sketch series ''
John Finnemore's Souvenir Programme'', first broadcast in 2011, features the recurring character of a storyteller (a fictionalised version of Finnemore) who tells tall tales partly influenced by M. R. James's ghost stories. During the ninth series broadcast in 2021, which underwent a format change due to the
coronavirus pandemic, Oswald 'Uncle Newt' Nightingale, analogous with Finnemore's storyteller character, meets M. R. James during the Christmas of 1898 as a young boy, who proceeds to tell him the story of
The Rose Garden. Later in Uncle Newt's life (or earlier in the series), he tells an iteration of said story whilst babysitting Deborah and Myra Wilkinson. In 2022, British
post punk band
Funboy Five released "Kissing the Ghost of M R James" and "A Warning to the Curious (Disturbed Mix)", a remix of a song, based on the James story, that first appeared on their 2019 release
An Autumn Collection. ==Adaptations==