In the late 1940s, taking ownership over from his parents, Morris Martick renamed the bar '''Martick's Tyson Street Tavern''' By the 1950s, Martick's was viewed as "Baltimore's intellectual meeting place" and one of "the roots of Baltimore bohemian culture."
Leonard Bernstein, on visits to the city, was known to play the bar's piano. The bar was open to gays, at a time when this was still uncommon in the city (and country). As early as the 1950s, the bar was known as an important gathering place for "not only gay men and women but other members of what is now called the
LGBTQ+ community, including bisexuals, crossdressers and people undergoing sex change operations by Johns Hopkins Hospital physician
John Money." Martick's is also cited as "one of the first
integrated bars in Baltimore," existing as such even while
de jure segregation was still in effect in the city. In later years, Martick would state in interviews that the tavern had not in fact been integrated while
Jim Crow was still on the books,
Harley Brinsfield). Future film director
John Waters frequented the area before he was of legal drinking age, loitering in the alley and depending on regulars to sneak him drinks. Waters, who visited with his friend, the future
drag icon
Divine, found Martick's a formative location for the group of artists that would eventually become known as the
Dreamlanders. It was at Martick's that Waters met Pat Moran, with whom he would collaborate on all of his feature films. It was also where Waters first met actor and projectionist
George Figgs.
Maelcum Soul, yet another early Waters collaborator, was a Martick's bartender, and also the subject of an art show there in 1965, featuring 25 portraits of her in the nude. Meanwhile, the neighborhood around Martick's continued to evolve: originally part of a block of
rowhouses, by 1950 the building at 214 West Mulberry Street was the last building of this type left on the block. Despite the Tavern's prestige among the arts community, Martick would reflect back on it in a 1981 interview as merely "a crummy bar... I mean a crummy one." ==Martick's Restaurant Francais==